Report: Monmouth Park Sees Equine Fatalities Rise For Third Straight Year

A report from NJ Advance Media revealed Friday that the number of equine fatalities at Monmouth Park has risen for a third straight year, averaging 2.05 deaths per 1,000 starts in 2022. The national average, reported by The Jockey Club, was 1.25 over the same period.

A total of 22 Thoroughbreds died at Monmouth in 2022, including six which occurred off the racetrack, outside of racing or training:

  • Kershaw, a 7-year-old , suffered a cervical fracture and was found with a three-centimeter-deep laceration on his forehead on Oct. 28. The Jose D'Angelo-trained gelding won a starter optional claiming race on Sept. 30 at Laurel in his final career start.
  • Classic Escape, a 3-year-old gelding, finished last in a race Aug. 29 after being “fractious just prior to the start” and hitting the gate, endured a broken tail and could no longer defecate before being euthanized days later on Sept. 4. (trainer Luis Carvajal, Jr.)
  • Hi Millie, a 3-year-old gelding, was discovered laying in his stall on July 26. Owner/trainer James Frangella, Jr. said that it was an adverse reaction to medication under a doctor's care.
  • Road to Meath, a 7-year-old gelding trained by Jack Abrams, was listed as a “Sudden Death @ rest” on Aug. 19. The pathologist listed respiratory distress and the ingestion of an anticoagulant rodenticide as possible causes of death.
  • Annas Candy, an insured 4-year-old filly, was found dead in the barn of trainer Jerry Hollendorfer on July 17. The fatality report said she flipped in the stall; her skull was fractured. A note added, “This horse attached to hoist.”
  • Miss Margaret Ann, a 6-year-old mare, died on June 25 with her cause of death listed as “colic.” (trainer John Pimental)

Additionally, four Standardbreds died at Meadowlands Racetrack, and one Standardbred fatality was reported at Freehold Raceway.

The report also points to the federal indictments of trainers Jorge Navarro and Jason Servis, both of whom were based at Monmouth Park in adjacent barns. Both trainers pled guilty; Navarro is one year into a five-year prison sentence, and Servis is scheduled to be sentenced a few days after this Saturday's Haskell.

It also highlights trainer Jerry Hollendorfer, who was banned from California tracks owned by The Stronach Group after a series of equine fatalities in 2019, and set up shop at Monmouth in 2020. Two of his trainees were among the death toll at Monmouth in 2022: the aforementioned Annas Candy, and Stratofortress, an uninsured 4-year-old gelding, who suffered a fracture on track and was euthanized. Hollendorfer recently transferred his Monmouth string to longtime assistant trainer Dan Ward.

Read more at NJ Advance Media.

The post Report: Monmouth Park Sees Equine Fatalities Rise For Third Straight Year appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

New Evidence In Servis Case Shows Trainer Lying To Owner, Hiding Drugs In Shampoo Bottles

On Thursday, federal prosecutors filed their pre-sentencing memo in the case of former trainer Jason Servis, attacking his attorneys' assertion that he was manipulated by his veterinarian and others into believing illegal drugs were safe to use.

“Jason Servis, an experienced, sophisticated, and vaunted thoroughbred racehorse trainer, reached the heights of his field through the corrupt administration of drugs to racehorses under his care and control,” the memo from assistant U.S. attorney Sarah Mortazavi began. “In order to hide his scheme, he lied, repeatedly, and persisted in his illegal conduct even when confronted with irrefutable proof that his conduct was dishonest and violated racing rules. He was under no illusions that his conduct was permissible. He was neither deceived nor manipulated.”

Prosecutors say that Servis fully understood that his use of SGF-1000 and clenbuterol went against regulations and released a number of new wiretap transcripts and other intercepted communications they believe demonstrate his attitude toward his activity.

The government is requesting a prison sentence between the 36 months assigned to veterinarian Dr. Kristian Rhein and the 48 months maximum outlined in sentencing guidelines for Servis. Servis entered a guilty plea late last year and is due to be sentenced by U.S. District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil next week.

Here are a few of our takeaways from the government's memo:

–As Maximum Security prepared for a run in the inaugural Saudi Cup, an email from owner Gary West to Servis urged the trainer to be careful to avoid any “accidental drug violation” in the race, which both knew could be subject to different medication rules from what they were used to in the States.

“I would feel horrible to win a life changing race like this for everyone only to find out we didn't do something right because we didn't know,” West wrote.

“Sounds good … just an FYI Max has never been on anything out of the ordinary,” Servis wrote back.

“Jason, that is great but 'over there' they might consider a 'sugar cube' illegal – I am not smart enough to know,” West wrote back. ”So, if you need any help figuring out their rules I will gladly pay for you to get whatever advice you need. Much of what you need can be found in the manual they sent and from the Saudi's [sic] who officiate the race and enforce the rules.”

–A pair of intercepted calls between Rhein and Michael Kegley, Jr., sales manager for MediVet shed light on the company's star product in SGF-1000.

SGF-1000 was sold exclusively through veterinarians, and prosecutors say Servis was sourcing it through another veterinarian besides Rhein.

Kegley: Well so Servis and his brother you know [redacted] is buying literally as much SGF as you are.

Rhien: Yeah

Kegley: So [redacted] is giving it to him as well.

–MediVet imported SGF-1000 and claimed on paperwork it was a “supplement.” It's not clear where the company was importing it from, but in our previous reporting we learned that it shared a name with a product marketed by Australian company Advanced Equine and Camel Solutions, whose website went down shortly after the FBI raided MediVet's offices. Marketing of SGF-1000 by Advanced Equine and Camel Solutions claimed it could help “obtain Super Performance with Super Natural Growth Factors” and would result in “improved stamina and performance levels” and “increased energy levels, vigor, stamina and desire for physical activity.”

In summer 2019, when Kegley and Rhein became concerned that there may be regulatory scrutiny of the product they brainstormed ways to stay in business. They mulled rebranding it with a new name and new packaging – although they pointed out that it was distributed solely by veterinarians, so the public wouldn't recognize its branding anyway. They also thought of ways to make it sound less heavy-hitting to anyone skeptical of its contents.

Kegley: …Well think of that, think of the name, think of like what we can, you know, say “it's been reported to…X” you know, “help with tendon and ligament”

Rhein: I know, you know what we should call it like, like …

Kegley: Something real vague, yeah…

Rhien: Like Repair…

Kegley: And we won't mention the word growth factor in any way shape or form

Rhein: 100%, we should call it something like RepairRX. Like Repair Treatment, and RX …

Kegley: Yeah

Rhein: Something like that that just, people go, “oh, repair.”

Kegley: Right, and we can even put ot he box, you know, dietary supplement for equine. That way it's not, no one even has to question if it's FDA approved or not, it's strictly a supplement

Editor's note: Dietary supplements are not regulated by the FDA, but injectable products may not, generally speaking, be considered dietary supplements since laypeople are not supposed to give injections.

–Servis was using both commercially-made clenbuterol and compounded clenbuterol he acquired from fellow trainer Jorge Navarro. Both believed the compounded clenbuterol was supposed to be stronger than the FDA-approved version of the drug. Servis went to great lengths to conceal compounded clenbuterol, hiding it inside buckets of poultice, shampoo bottles, and rolls of self-adhesive bandage. He would send those containers on horse vans or in employees' vehicles, and later told law enforcement that they could see from his car's EZ Pass information he hadn't been shuttling drugs to other racetracks when they questioned him in summer 2019.

Servis and Navarro both seemed prepared for the possibility that officials could search their barns at any time and were aware they would open boxes and could check vehicles for contraband. They arranged to have third parties hand off the compounded clenbuterol from Navarro's operation to Servis' although names beyond that of Servis assistant Henry Argueta are redacted.

Argueta was originally named on the March 2020 federal indictment but was absent from a later superseding indictment.

–Two exhibits contain pages of intercepted conversations between Argueta and Servis, with Servis warning him to be careful to make sure no one observing the barn would see anything amiss. Servis told Argueta that Navarro was maintaining his treatment plan by coming to the backstretch himself to treat horses at 11 p.m.

–Navarro and Servis compared notes on which racing officials they viewed as friendly and which were sticklers for medication regulation and would confiscate substances they deemed illegal. As has been seen in previous evidence, Navarro claimed at least one official warned him ahead of time when a barn search or a visit from regulators was imminent.

All names of officials in this exchange are redacted.

–There was some regulatory interest in Maximum Security in June 2019 – a month after his first-place finish in the Kentucky Derby (from which he was disqualified for interference). He was out-of-competition tested on June 3 and again June 5. He had just received SGF-1000 on June 3. Servis was unsure whether the testing in both instances was just for the New Jersey Racing Commission or whether The Jockey Club could also be involved.

Rhein had previously assured Servis that SGF-1000 would evade testing and, if anything, may show up as a false positive for dexamethasone.

Editor's note: Testing experts tell us this is chemically impossible.

Servis called an unnamed veterinarian who did his work in New Jersey and suggested that the billing for the horse should reflect a dexamethasone administration from June 3. The veterinarian later called Servis back and confirmed “He got the dex Monday.”

According to prosecutors, Argueta requested Servis send him more compounded clenbuterol for Maximum Security on July 8, 2019 and also indicated he needed the drug for World of Trouble.

–Again, the intercepted conversations in this filing remind readers that even the people selling SGF-1000 didn't really know what was in it. In the transcript between Kegley and Rhein, both of whom agreed they were “99 percent sure” there was no growth hormone in the product, but they were concerned that testing of the product had found levamisole that Rhein said is “a big no-no even at trace levels.”

“We're 99 percent sure this is all just gonna fizzle, go away,” Kegley told Rhein. “because he's under the impression they're gonna test and that they're gonna do what the guy that you talked to Jason says, 'These idiots, they think they're helping these horses? They're not doing anything. We're not wasting our time with this, and then we'll just quietly move along like we always have.'”

The post New Evidence In Servis Case Shows Trainer Lying To Owner, Hiding Drugs In Shampoo Bottles appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Mott: HISA ‘Making A Federal Crime’ Of Working Art Collector Too Early

Hall of Fame trainer Bill Mott has expressed his frustration over what he calls a “mistake” with the schedule of Grade 1 winner Art Collector, reports bloodhorse.com.

According to records released by the Horseracing Integrity and Welfare Unit (HIWU), the enforcement arm of the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority (HISA), the 6-year-old Art Collector received an intra-articular injection on June 21. HISA regulations restrict both workouts and races for horses which have received intra-articular injections; they must be 7 days out from a work, and 14 days from a race.

Mott worked Art Collector on June 26 at Saratoga, landing the Grade 1 winner on a list of provisionally suspended horses which would be ineligible to race or breeze for 30 days from the date of injections.

“I worked the horse one day early; I didn't even give it a second thought,” Mott told bloodhorse.com. “I was not supposed to work him for one more day and now they are making a federal crime out of it? It's an easy mistake to make. I breezed the horse one day early. … I am looking at the horse. I'm trying to be a horse trainer.”

(Per an advisory issued Thursday morning by the Thoroughbred Horsemen's Association, Mott actually worked Art Collector two days early. The horse was injected on a Wednesday, and was not eligible to work until the following Wednesday, but Mott breezed him on Monday.)

Art Collector has not worked since June 26 at Saratoga, but had been expected to run in the $400,000 Monmouth Cup Stakes (G3) at Monmouth Park July 22, one day after the end of his provisional suspension. Mott told bloodhorse.com that the horse had come up with a hoof abscess “three or four days ago” and thus had not been entered.

Now, the plans calls for Art Collector to defend his two-year reign over the $1 million Charles Town Classic (G2) on Aug. 25.

“I am all for uniform rules and regulations, but uniform rules and regulations that make sense,” Mott told bloodhorse.com. “All of a sudden, they throw out all this stuff that doesn't make any sense at all.”

There has been significant confusion over the intra-articular injection rule, HISA admitted earlier this month. Rather than sanction the group of confused trainers with the initial punishment listed in the regulations, a 60-day suspension, HISA opted to suspend the horses from racing or breezing for 30 days.

However, beginning on July 16, HISA will begin utilizing new enforcement protocols announced earlier this week.

“Effective July 16, HIWU will sanction the responsible person of any covered horse that violates the prohibition on intra-articular injections within seven days prior to a timed and reported workout as follows (within a 365-day rolling period):

  • 1st violation: $3,000 fine.
  • 2nd violation: $6,000 fine, 10-day suspension.
  • 3rd violation: $10,000 fine, 30-day suspension.
  • 4th violation: $20,000 fine, 60-day suspension.
  • 5th violation: $25,000 fine, 120-day suspension.”

Read more at bloodhorse.com.

The post Mott: HISA ‘Making A Federal Crime’ Of Working Art Collector Too Early appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

‘Ship & Win’ Program Continues To Attract Out-Of-Staters To Del Mar

Most of the architects of the popular “Ship & Win” program at Del Mar refuse to take credit for saving horse racing in Southern California. Admittedly, the term “saving” may be a bit of an overstatement but there's no denying that the successful program has breathed new life into the region.

“Ship & Win” enters its 13th season at Del Mar in 2023. The program provides incentives for out-of-town trainers and owners to bring their horses to the seaside oval. If a horse has made their last start outside of the state, they get a bonus just for running, $5,000 for dirt runners, $4,000 for turf. Then on top of the bonus they get a purse supplement, 50 percent for dirt, 40 percent for turf.

Last year, over 200 horses qualified for the “Ship & Win” bonus and made over 300 starts at Del Mar. This year racing secretary David Jerkens believes the numbers will be similar.

“'Ship & Win' was up 20-percent last year,” Jerkens says. “It was a big component of our success last summer. I don't know if we'll be at the level of last year but I think we'll be in the ballpark.

“When you attract out-of-state barns that bring 20 head,” Jerkens says, “like last year we had Diodoro and Sisterson, that inflates the numbers. Typically most of the starts are from local trainers. 60-to-70 percent are local. Then you throw in out-of-state barns that are not just sending a stakes horse and you get that eight-horse field that might have been a six or that 10-horse field that might have been an eight. You just look at the card and you see how many extra horses are from the 'Ship & Win' program.”

Overall, an estimated 2,400 horses have participated in the “Ship & Win” program since it began in 2011. This has led to increased field sizes, not only at Del Mar but at other racetracks around the state.

“We opened it up for Santa Anita,” Jerkens says, “where an eligible horse can make two starts at Santa Anita in May and June and still be eligible for purse bonuses at Del Mar. And at the Santa Anita autumn meet, horses remain eligible as long as they've made one start at Del Mar.”

The ripple effect of these horses shipping in to Del Mar is that many are staying and racing in Southern California.

“We've kept track of the horses,” Jerkens says, “and we've seen evidence that a majority of them remain on the circuit. Typically they'll stay in the state and make another start of two.”

In addition to “Ship & Win” there's the Maiden Incentive Program, a 25 percent purse supplement for owners and trainers who run their horses in Maiden Special Weight dirt races, MSW Cal-bred dirt races, and maiden claiming dirt races of $62,000 and above. That translates into big bucks for an owner who brings their horse from out-of-state and wins one of the qualifying maiden races.

The Del Mar summer meet begins Friday.

The post ‘Ship & Win’ Program Continues To Attract Out-Of-Staters To Del Mar appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights