Antoinette Proves Tough Cookie On Front End In The Very One

Jockey Jose Ortiz put Antoinette on the lead at the start, and the Godolphin homebred filly by Hard Spun was never headed, winning the Grade 3, $125,000 The Very One Stakes at Gulfstream Park on Saturday in Hallandale Beach, Fla.

Trained by Hall of Famer Bill Mott, Antoinette proved 2 1/4 lengths the best, paying $9.20 as the tepid 7-2 favorite in the field of nine fillies and mares going 1 3/16 miles on firm turf. She covered the distance in 1:53.70 after clicking off easy fractions of :23.98, :49.11, 1:13.24, and 1:36.67.

Belle Laura finished second, a neck ahead of Sister Hanan, with Tuned a head back in fourth and War Like Goddess finishing fifth.

The victory was the fourth in 11 starts for Antoinette, who hasn't raced since an eighth-place finish in the G3 Valley View Stakes at Keeneland  last Oct. 18. Prior to that she ran second to Magic Attitude in the G1 Belmont Oaks Invitational, one month after winning the Saratoga Oaks in similar wire to wire fashion.

Saturday was a big day for Sheikh Mohammed's Godolphin. In addition to Antoinette's victory, a pair of homebred runners won rich graded stakes at Oaklawn: Mystic Guide winning the G3, $600,000 Razorback Handicap and champion Essential Quality winning the G3, $750,000 Southwest Stakes in his 2021 debut.

The post Antoinette Proves Tough Cookie On Front End In The Very One appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Greatest Honour Closes With A Rush To Win Fountain Of Youth Going Away

Eight and a half lengths behind the leader with five-sixteenths of a mile to run, Courtlandt Farms' homebred Greatest Honour, closed with a rush under Jose Ortiz to win Saturday's Grade 2, $300,000 Fasig-Tipton Fountain of Youth Stakes at Gulfstream Park in Hallandale Beach, Fla.

Trained by Shug McGaughey, the 3-year-old colt by leading sire Tapit (who also was represented on Saturday by G3 Southwest Stakes winner Essential Quality, the 2-year-old male champion of 2020) ran 1 1/16 miles in 1:44.02 on a fast track.

Pacesetter Drain the Clock  – who posted fractions of :23.66, :47.18, 1:11.51 and 1:37.45 and held a 2 1/2-length lead at the eighth pole – finished second, 1 1/2 lengths behind Greatest Honour. Papetu was another two lengths back in third, with Tarantino fourth and Jirafales fifth in the field of 10.

The Fountain of Youth, a 1 1/16-mile key prep for the $750,000 Curlin Florida Derby (G1) presented by Hill n' Dale Farm at Xalapa March 27, headlined a 14-race program with nine stakes, eight graded.

The Fountain of Youth offered 85 qualifying points to the Kentucky Derby, with the first four finishers receiving 50-20-10-5.

Updated Kentucky Derby Leaderboard

Greatest Honor lagged far back while racing in traffic early but made steady progress approaching the far turn. Drain the Clock continued to show the way under Edgard Zayas around the far turn and into the homestretch as Papetu, the early trailer, made a sweeping move around Greatest Honour to enter contention under Junior Alvarado.

The long-striding Greatest Honour was steered to the outside while building momentum on the turn into the homestretch and kicked in powerfully through the stretch to sweep past Papetu and catch Drain the Clock approaching the finish line. Greatest Honour galloped out strongly, suggesting he may get better as the distances get longer.

“He was a little farther back that I thought he would be going down the backside. A lot of dirt was hitting him. They weren't going overly fast. Going three-quarters in 1:11 and change over this track is not fast,” McGaughey said. “When Jose got him in the clear it was over.”

Ortiz, who was aboard for the considerably easier 5 ¾-length Holy Bull victory, said Greatest Honor's momentum was briefly stopped on the far turn.

“He's such a big horse with such a big stride. At the three-eighths [pole] I'm trying to get him going and I got a space on the inside but I didn't what to stop him again,” Ortiz said. “I decided to go wide and when he hit the clear, boom!”

McGaughey is hoping that Greatest Honour will follow the example of Orb, whom he saddled for victories in the 2017 Fountain of Youth, the 1 1/8-mile Florida Derby and the 1 ¼-mile Kentucky Derby.

“I'm glad we don't have to run a mile and a sixteenth anymore,” McGaughey said. “When they're going farther, I think we might see a little better horse.”

Fire At Will, who captured the Nov. 6 Breeders' Cup Juvenile Turf (G1) at Keeneland, stalked the early pace before fading to eighth.

$300,000 Fasig-Tipton Fountain of Youth (G2) Quotes

Trainer Shug McGaughey (Greatest Honour, 1st): “I wasn't real comfortable. I could see what was going on and I felt like if [jockey Jose Ortiz] got him in the clear then we could have a shot to make a run at him. The horse that was second [Drain the Clock], when he did break clear I said, 'Uh, oh.' But, he's a really nice horse.”

“The pace wasn't that fast today, I don't think, but he was able to overcome it. He's won twice down here now in stakes doing what he doesn't want to do, and that's a mile and a sixteenth. Like Jose said, I'm glad these mile and a sixteenth [races] are behind us. We'll be looking forward to getting him stretched out. Hopefully it's in the near future but, if not, I know what we've got. Hopefully as we keep going longer he'll keep improving. The farther the better for him.”

“He does cover a lot of ground. I don't know that he's really that quick, as much as he just covers so much ground and he can get to horses so quick. And he did today. He got to that horse pretty quick.”

“It was the kickback. Jose said he wasn't wanting to run through the dirt. He was wanting to get him to the outside and they were kind of holding him in there. Then he said they bumped over there on the turn and he kind of lost his rear end a little bit.”

Florida Derby? – “That would be my plan.”

Jockey Jose Ortiz (Greatest Honour, 1st): “He broke good, a bit slow like he always does, and I put him in the race. I tried to be as close as I could going to the backside and I got a good path behind Prime Factor. But, when we hit the turn I bumped the horse outside of me and lose my hind end a little bit and it was very hard to get him back going. He's such a big horse with such a big stride. At the three-eighths pole I'm trying to get him going and I got a space on the inside but I didn't want to have to stop him again, so I decided to go wide and when he hit the clear, boom. He was there for me. Huge run.”

“Not just this race. I won the first one [Holy Bull] and the second one, now we're going to the Florida Derby and if we could sweep the three legs that would be great momentum going into the Derby. I know there's a lot of time left and anything can happen. We just pray for the best and stay healthy. I know if the Florida Derby we're going to face tough competition, for sure.”

Owner Donald Adam, Courtlandt Farm (Greatest Honour, 1st): “It's very exciting. Being a horse that I bred and the history by which I came by him is very gratifying. I was a little concerned in this one. It looked like he wasn't in the best position, but this will be the shortest race he runs in a long time. And the longer he goes, the better he will be.”

“I bought the mare [Tiffany's Honour] in foal to a Tapit colt and that colt hit the ground and was killed in a paddock accident. So, I bred her back to Tapit and got him. I bought her at a Fasig-Tipton sale.”

Trainer Saffie Joseph Jr. (Drain the Clock, 2nd): “He ran huge. He ran like a winner. I didn't even see the winner coming. I saw Papetu coming and he ran good. Obviously, the winner is a very good horse. We can't be disappointed. It was his first time at the distance and he was beaten by a quality horse.”

Florida Derby? – “We're undecided. We'll talk it over with the owners and then we'll see what they want to do and how he comes out and go from there.”

Jockey Edgard Zayas (Drain the Clock, 2nd): “He did everything right. It's always a question if he could handle the two turns and I think he handled it pretty well. The winner has way more experience than him going two turns and for his first time going two turns, I think he ran a great race. I think he should try it again and he'll probably get better. If not, he can go back to sprinting but I think he deserves another shot.”

The post Greatest Honour Closes With A Rush To Win Fountain Of Youth Going Away appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Jockey Hector Rafael Diaz Jr. Driven By Hope That His Brother Will Walk Again

When Hector Rafael Diaz, Jr., dreams about racing against his brother, he can't identify the track or what horse he's riding. He doesn't know if it is a stakes or a $5,000 claiming race.

All that remains is the pure joy of competition.

As the siblings turn for home, their horses vying head-to-head, neither jockey gives an inch. Each seems to know what the other is thinking, and Hector Rafael's adrenaline skyrockets from the thrill of knowing that he and young Hector Miguel are living the life they were meant for.

When he wakes up, Hector Rafael is unsure who won. He snaps into a harsh reality, the scenario so vivid in his mind only a fantasy.

But there is no time to dwell on sadness or regrets. Hector Miguel, 27 (“Migue,” to family and friends), is back home in Trujillo Alto, Puerto Rico, in a wheelchair, paralyzed from the waist down by a riding accident at Hipodromo Camarero in Canovanas on Jan. 3, 2015, almost two years before Hector Rafael rode his first race.

Chances are, Migue already has studied the past performances for his brother's mounts at Tampa Bay Downs and is ready to offer his observations and advice by phone.

Leaving home before daylight to work horses and get ready for the races, Hector Rafael kisses his fiancée Deyanyra and her 3-year-old son, Andrew. Being at Tampa Bay Downs, where he is tied for third place in the standings with 38 victories, feels like a dream come true.

A dream he shares with his brother.

“I would have loved to ride with him, to compete against him,” said the 31-year-old Diaz, whose 18.5-percent strike rate at the meeting is fourth-best at Tampa Bay Downs among jockeys with 100 or more starts. “In my dream, I think my brother beats me sometimes and I beat him sometimes. But it doesn't really matter. It's just us doing what we love, what we dreamed of doing.”

Their father, Hector Rafael Diaz, Sr., was also a jockey, retiring in his mid-30s after incurring more than his share of injuries. Neither he nor their mother, Norma Sanchez, wanted the boys to become jockeys, but years of going to Camarero to watch their father compete had already stoked their passion. Having an even more well-known pair of brothers as cousins and neighbors – Irad Ortiz, Jr., and Jose Ortiz – provided more fuel for the Diaz boys' fire.

“Every parent wants their kid to be a doctor or a lawyer and have a good career. I was a good student, and they wanted me to keep studying,” Diaz said. “But my brother and I went to the races every weekend to watch our father race, and we both came to want it.

“My brother didn't do it for money. He loved riding horses, and I'm the same way. This is not a job for me.”

The brothers talk on a daily basis, the discussion usually coming around to the horses Hector Rafael rode, or is scheduled to ride. “Migue is on top of all my horses,” said Diaz. “I call him when I finish working to talk about the races and I call him after the last race. He'll tell me what he thinks about the horses I'm riding, and we'll go over how to ride a race if 'Plan A' goes out the window when the gate opens.”

Migue, who is married with a 7-year-old son, Jesier, who wants to be a jockey, watches races from numerous tracks through his TVG account, but he is laser-focused on Tampa Bay Downs as his older brother climbs the ladder of success.

“His brother follows everything he does,” said Shawn Klotz, Diaz's agent. “From what Hector tells me, his brother could flat-out ride. He was one of the best jockeys out there.”

The record bears that out. During his three-year career, which began in 2012 when he was 19, Migue won 477 races from 2,558 mounts – an 18.6-percent strike rate – and captured three graded stakes in Puerto Rico, including two Grade Is.

“I thought he was the best rider I'd ever seen. We don't know how good he could have been,” said Hector Rafael.

Around the same time Migue's career was taking off, Hector Rafael, then 23, enrolled in the Escuela La Vocacional Hipica jockey school. He stayed there a year, then headed to New York to work as an exercise rider for trainer George Weaver.

In the fall of 2014, Migue moved north to reunite with his brother and ride at Belmont Park, Laurel, Aqueduct and Meadowlands. He managed four winners from 42 mounts, but the combination of the unfamiliar surroundings, a language barrier and frigid weather led him to return to Puerto Rico before the year ended.

That December, Hector Rafael took a vacation from his job for Weaver, returning home for the holidays. He was at the beach when Migue called him from the racetrack, reminding him he had one more race to ride and asking him to wait for his arrival.

About 20 minutes later, Irad Ortiz, Jr., called Hector Rafael and told him his brother had been in an accident. The horse inside Migue's mount came out a little, his horse clipped heels and the rider tumbled off, landing on his head and paralyzing his lower body.

Life can never be the same for an athlete who becomes paralyzed, especially one nearing the prime of their career. A little more than six years later, Migue sounds matter-of-fact about his accident, almost as if it had been an out-of-body experience he viewed through a camera lens. What beats inside him is perhaps best left between himself, family members and God, but he never blamed the sport or anyone else for what happened.

“I knew the risk when I chose to become a jockey,” Migue said in a recent Facetime conversation, which Hector Rafael translated for a reporter. “You know something like that can happen, but you don't think about it.

“God had other plans for me, and I'm following that. I am my brother's No. 1 fan, and I take his victories like they are mine.”

The Diaz brothers with their mother, Norma Sanchez

After the accident, their parents implored Hector Rafael to give up his dream and pursue another career. But he had already made up his mind.

“I had always wanted to be a jockey, but my brother getting hurt made me want it even more,” he said. “I thought, he can't do it anymore, so now it's my turn. I told my parents 'I respect your feelings, but this is what I love, and this is what I'm going to do.' I have to stay strong for him. He's not showing weakness, so I can't show weakness.”

While his brother began the arduous task of rehabilitation and learning to cope with a new way of life, Diaz returned to New York for more seasoning. His moment of reckoning came in a claiming race at Aqueduct on Nov. 11, 2016, when he rode Weaver's 3-year-old filly Shoppingforsilver, owned by West Point Thoroughbreds, to a second-place finish in his first career race.

“It was me, Javier Castellano, Irad and Jose, and Manuel Franco (and Addiel Ayala) in that race. All good jockeys,” Diaz recalls, smiling at the memory. “I was a little nervous, but I enjoyed it. Being in the jockeys' room in New York was a great education. I learned a lot from guys like Cornelio Velasquez and Kendrick Carmouche, and Irad and Jose. You could go to any corner of that room and learn things from jockeys who were glad to share their knowledge.”

His first career victory on Jan. 15, 2017, aboard Honorable Jonas launched a year in which Diaz rode 74 winners, earning recognition as a finalist for an Eclipse Award as Outstanding Apprentice Jockey. Another graduate of Puerto Rico's jockey school, Evin Roman, won the award, but by staying in New York, Diaz established his ability to compete against many of the finest jockeys in the country.

“I started working with Hector that summer at Monmouth Park, and we won a bunch of races,” said Klotz, his agent. “Winning is what gets a jockey into new barns, and there were a lot of good outfits that wanted to use him.

“Hector studies races, he listens and he is always willing to learn. He is very patient – he isn't going to make a premature move that gets a horse beat. He'll sit and wait for his chance to pounce, but if there is no speed in a race, he's comfortable being on the lead,” Klotz said.

Last year, Diaz finished fifth in the standings at Monmouth with 30 victories. That performance came after he fractured three vertebrae in a fall at Aqueduct, causing him to miss six weeks, followed by almost three months off due to track closures caused by COVID-19.

Toward the end of Monmouth's season, trainer Michael Stidham's assistant, Ben Trask, suggested Diaz forgo New York's lucrative purses and give Tampa Bay Downs a shot. After weighing the pros and cons, Diaz decided it could only benefit his career exposing his talent to a brand-new audience.

“When I left New York last fall (soon after riding trainer Arnaud Delacour's 2-year-old colt Arrest Me Red to victory in the Atlantic Beach Stakes at Aqueduct on Nov. 6), I felt like the best rider out there,” Diaz said. “No disrespect to anybody; there are a lot of great riders who if they've got the horse, are going to show their talent. But when I'm riding races, I feel like I can do anything they can and nobody can outsmart me. That's the confidence I built being in New York with all those good riders.”

Diaz has won eight times for the Stidham barn this season, while also winning races for 16 other outfits. But Trask said the decision to use Diaz as the stable's “go-to” jockey in Oldsmar was based on more than his ability to win races.

Diaz winning aboard Skol Chant for trainer Michael Stidham

“It's very hard for someone who has never been here before to come in and be successful, because you have a handful of guys, like (Samy) Camacho and (Antonio) Gallardo and (Daniel) Centeno, who win a lot of races,” Trask said. “But Hector was already part of our team, and he knows what it takes to get the job done.

“Anybody can win a race. But Hector is a team player who got to see what happens behind the scenes when he worked for George Weaver, and that makes a big difference,” Trask said. “I have 40 people working in our barn, and he knows all their names and speaks to everybody when he comes to work. Hector never has a chip on his shoulder. When one of our guys shows up in the paddock with a horse, he greets them with respect.”

Kathleen O'Connell, who also uses Diaz on many of her horses, has helped cultivate the careers of numerous good jockeys, including Gallardo. She believes Diaz has the skill, confidence and courage to be as good as any of them.

“He is already polished, and I think he has a great future if he keeps doing what he's doing,” O'Connell said. “He is smart enough to know that you learn every day. You always need luck and the right horses and everything else, but as long as he keeps an open mind, he will keep progressing.”

O'Connell said Diaz's style puts horses at ease. “There is a big difference between taking a light hold and strangling a horse, and he has very kind hands on a horse and is astute as to how they are traveling. He cares about the animals and is a good communicator.”

After competing in New York as a proverbial small fish in a big pond, Diaz is getting noticed on a widespread basis. He is comfortable with his status as one of the top four jockeys this season at Tampa Bay Downs and the extra attention that comes with it.

“To be up there with guys like Gallardo and Centeno, who have won multiple titles, and Camacho, that is amazing,” Klotz said. “Those guys are cornerstones of Tampa Bay.”

Diaz – who has an 11-year-old daughter, Heclian, and a 2-year-old son, Jayden, from previous relationships – yearns to see his brother and his parents soon; he hasn't been home in a few years. He says his parents are more accepting of his career choice and proud at how he represents himself and the family.

“My father calls me a lot to talk about the horses and my career. I know it's tough for parents to see their kid can't walk, and I know there are nights when they cry in bed,” Diaz said. “But Migue is alive, and that's how we have to view it.”

In surroundings that are often hectic, when every move he makes can mean the difference between winning and losing, Diaz puts everything else out of his mind. But win or lose, he is uplifted knowing Migue provides another set of eyes that are invaluable in helping to keep the family tradition strong.

“My brother is my hero. I don't think I would ever have taken what happened the way he does,” Diaz said. “He is the one who gave me the big push to do what I am doing now. I don't know why, but I never think about his accident. I pray God to protect all of us riders on the track, but we got to compete. When I'm on top of a horse, I just think about winning the race.”

Diaz has another dream, one he carries in his heart. “I always say if I do real good, I want to take him somewhere to doctors who can help him walk again. That is my goal. He is grateful he is alive, and I am grateful he is alive. We know things could be a lot worse. But there is always a hope, and we never lose that.”

It is a dream worth sharing, with the racetrack community and the world.

The post Jockey Hector Rafael Diaz Jr. Driven By Hope That His Brother Will Walk Again appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

‘A Stupid, Stupid Rule’: New York Restrictions On Married Jockeys Stifling Davis’ Business

“The dumbest rule in racing.”

That's how attorney Bill Gotimer said TVG analysts have described New York's Commission Rule 4040.2 which reads: “No jockey, nor such jockeys' spouse, parent, issue nor member of such jockey's household, shall be the owner of any race horse. All horses trained or ridden by a spouse, parent, issue or member of a jockey's household shall be coupled in the betting with any horse ridden by such jockey.”

The rule has become a topic of discussion in recent weeks as Gotimer said it has recently begun hindering the business of his client, jockey Katie Davis, since her marriage to fellow rider Trevor McCarthy.

Davis married McCarthy in December 2020 and the couple shifted their tack from Maryland to New York. They were later informed that since their marriage, Rule 4040.2 would require the racing office to couple their mounts whenever they rode in the same race, whether or not their horses had the same trainer or owner.

McCarthy has gotten off to a swimming beginning in New York, riding 19 winners from 154 starters this year for mount earnings over $1 million, putting him well on his way to surpassing last year's total earnings. Davis, by contrast, has had just one win from 53 mounts so far, despite coming into the season off two strong years in Maryland. Just before their departure, McCarthy was a leading rider at Laurel Park, while Davis was seventh in the standings there.

Mike Monroe, current agent for Davis, and Gary Contessa, who had her book briefly after her move to New York, both agree that the rule has negatively impacted Davis's ability to get mounts. Both heard from trainers who had named Davis on their horses, only to take her off after they learned about the coupling rule. Media reports have indicated the racing office at Aqueduct has discouraged trainers from using Davis in races where McCarthy is already named, since it would not cause a coupling of what would otherwise be two betting interests in the race. The New York Racing Association has categorically denied that racing office personnel have exerted pressure on trainers not to use Davis.

“It's a stupid, stupid rule,” said Contessa. “It's absolutely ridiculous. When I was booking her, I had a trainer – I'll not say who – who's a bettor. Most trainers are lousy bettors, but they like to bet on their horses and this guy liked to bet. This guy gave me four calls for Katie and two or three days later he told me 'Gary I can't do it because I can't have these horses coupled. I want to get 10-1, I don't want to get 3-1.'

“On the racing office side, they're losing a betting interest and if you really evaluate betting races, losing one betting interest or gaining one betting interest earns or decrease that race by about $100,000 in wagers.”

Monroe said the rule does apply equally to Davis and McCarthy – if McCarthy is named on a mount after Davis, the trainer of McCarthy's horse will be informed that they will be coupled with Davis's mount – but McCarthy is booking mounts so quickly that he's usually named first. Monroe admits the mounts Davis has gotten have not done as well as they would have hoped, but is confident the coupling issue is the primary reason her career has stalled in New York.

“All we're really asking for is a fair shake, a level playing field. It's not a level playing field right now,” said Monroe. “We all know the racing office is having a difficult time with a shortage of entries, but that should not impact Katie Davis' status of being named on a horse. That's what we're trying to bring out here.”

Where did this rule come from?

Although Rule 4040.2 has become a target of complaint for Davis and her supporters recently, the New York State Gaming Commission told Gotimer it has been on the books since at least September 1974.

Though the rule is negatively impacting a female rider in 2021, a letter from New York State Gaming Commission executive director Robert Williams points out the rule is not written to only apply to female riders. It's true however, that the rule (logically) seems to have come about after women became licensed by New York state, which happened in 1969. And Monroe and Gotimer point out that the rule is going to naturally be unevenly impactful towards which ever spouse has less career momentum.

“There's going to be a day when you face this question with same-sex spouses,” said Gotimer.

Part of the reason the rule about married jockeys may have seemed dormant for the past 47 years is that there have been relatively few instances where married jockeys have tried to ride against each other in New York. The closest comparable case in recent memory may be Jose Ortiz and Taylor Rice Ortiz, but Taylor said they never had the opportunity to find out how the rule may have impacted their careers.

Taylor and Jose were engaged for some months before their wedding in December 2016. Taylor said she didn't know about Rule 4040.2 and was planning to continue with her career as a jockey, but found out she was pregnant with the couple's first child shortly before the wedding, prompting her to retire. Taylor, who has many immediate and extended family members in the sport, said she knew that marriage could complicate things.

The Ortiz family as of 2017

“I had heard of my dad's generation had been married and they had conflicts, and I knew that if you're a jockey and you're married to a trainer, you have to ride for your significant other,” said Ortiz. “What Trevor and Katie are going through, I had no idea the extent of it.”

 

That doesn't mean that she can see the logic in New York's rule. After all, she points out, she rode for her aunt, trainer Linda Rice, on many occasions but also rode for other trainers in races where Rice was saddling an entry and was never coupled in those races. She lived with Ortiz for several months before their marriage – an arrangement that was common knowledge on the backstretch – and that did not result in the racing office coupling their entries.

During the summer, when many riders, trainers, and others descend upon Saratoga Springs from out of town, Taylor Ortiz said it's also common for family members and close friends to share rental houses, as Jose and Irad Ortiz have done in the past, and cohabitation hasn't resulted in entries being coupled.

“What's crazy to me is that the horse racing industry is so intertwined between family and marriage,” said Ortiz. “So we could have stayed engaged forever, but as soon as we sign documents saying we're married it's a problem for one of your rules? It doesn't make sense to me.”

In initial research, Gotimer said he could find no other rule currently on the books in other major American racing jurisdictions that places the same kind of restrictions on riders as the New York State Gaming Commission. Instead, he found that cases where states or tracks had restrictions on married jockeys and had subsequently removed them.

In 1998, married riders Harry Vega and Amy Duross were told by Suffolk Downs stewards they couldn't ride in the same race, but that policy was later overturned by the Massachusetts Racing Commission. When jockeys Angel Serpa and Carol Cedeno were married, they competed against one another on uncoupled horses in Florida.

“[The restriction is] based in two concepts, neither one of which are really acceptable,” said Gotimer. “One is that licensed parties in New York state, and in particular jockeys, can't be trusted. I think that's a wild insult to world-class athletes.

“I think the second point is that it's based on an anachronistic idea that one spouse controls another. I don't see that in racing, and I don't see that in New York.”

Gotimer said he has not been retained for the purpose of bringing any legal action against the commission, but is hopeful the two sides can reach some kind of agreement about improved rule language.

“The Commission has commenced an examination of the rule origin, the harm it sought to prevent, its present applicability, and in what manner the harm – if any – can be addressed by alternative means,” said commission spokesman Brad Maione. “Additionally, we are seeking to place the rule in context, considering how similar situations are governed in other regional racing jurisdictions, in larger U.S. racing states and in major international jurisdictions.

“The rule appears by its plain language to be integrity-based with neutral applicability, but we intend on undertaking a de novo review.”

The rule has impacts on jockey/trainer combinations, too

Though Rule 4040.2 has mostly been discussed in the context of its impacts to two married jockeys, it has also come up for married trainer/jockey duos in New York.

Rachel Sells, who has had her trainer's license since 2017, is married to jockey Jose Soñe and is based at Finger Lakes. When she takes a horse to a race at a New York Racing Association track, Soñe must either sit the race out or ride her horse – he cannot ride for a competing trainer. At Finger Lakes, she said they were initially told that Soñe could ride other trainers' horses running against hers, but his mount would be coupled with her horse if he did so. Sells pushed back.

“We had issues with the racing office a few times,” she said. “I'm not one to sit back and let things happen. I'm a very vocal person. One day I called the racing office after I was informed my husband got taken off a horse because I had a horse in the race and I let them know they were denying him the right to a living and that's illegal. You can't tell somebody not to ride him because it's going to make the body of the race smaller.”

Eventually, Finger Lakes changed its house rules on the issue.

It's not a problem for Soñe to give first preference to Sells' horses, but for a rider with a wide client base, it might be. Taylor Ortiz pointed to the case of Rosie Napravnik, who had long been one of the go-to riders for Mike Maker when her husband, former Maker assistant Joe Sharp, opened his own training barn. Napravnik retired in 2014 upon learning that she was pregnant, not long after Sharp put out his shingle, so they didn't have much chance to find out how much her business may have been limited by the requirement that she give preference to Sharp's horses.

When saddling at her home base of Finger Lakes, Sells is still not permitted to own horses herself because she lives with Soñe, which she said has forced her to pass up great business opportunities. When she travels to a NYRA facility or anywhere out of state however, she encounters no problems running horses as both owner and trainer.

“For me, I could see if I do own a horse and I have a horse in the race, he has to ride that horse; I understand that,” she said. “But it's not even just for me. I have a groom who works for me and she's dating a jockey and wanted to buy a horse last year. I called the stewards and asked them about it and they said no, because she cohabitates with a jockey. It's not even just for trainers.”

Soñe doesn't ride as many races these days, though Sells said that's not because he has to give her first call as a trainer. Soñe has been a licensed rider since 2001 and while Sells said he will decide for himself when to hang his tack up, he isn't taking as many mounts as he once did.

“He's a lot more cautious on who he chooses to ride for,” she said. “At some point I do want him to be able to retire from riding and just come be with me and not have to worry about it.”

After all, being a jockey is a tough gig.

The post ‘A Stupid, Stupid Rule’: New York Restrictions On Married Jockeys Stifling Davis’ Business appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights