Value Bloodline Showcase: Tony Wolfe On Charming Kitten

In “Value Bloodline Showcase,” we'll look at stallions that offer value in regional marketplaces, with interviews from the operations that stand them.

In this edition, Tony Wolfe DVM of Wolfe Equine Services, discusses Charming Kitten, a graded stakes-winning son of Kitten's Joy who stands at Breakway Farm in Dillsboro, Ind. Charming Kitten's  first foals are yearlings of 2022.

Charming Kitten
Dk. b. or br. h., 2010, Kitten's Joy x Iteration, by Wild Again
Race Record: 33-8-8-3; $1,018,701
Advertised Fee: $2,500

Question: Charming Kitten was Indiana's most active stallion by mares bred in 2021. To what do you attribute that popularity?

Tony Wolfe, Breakway Farm: I think the simplest reason is that he's the total package. He's a gorgeous horse – correct conformation, built right, and very easy on the eyes. When you look at him, you don't even have to know what you're looking at, you just know you're looking at a true athlete.

He has the pedigree to back it up: A direct son of Kitten's Joy – if you don't know about Kitten's Joy, then COVID has had you isolated for too long. On top of the pedigree, he has a proven record. He earned over $1 million. He won the Grade 3 W.L. McKnight Handicap, and combined won or placed in 15 stakes races. He raced against tough fields and proved his worth.

He also crosses well with most pedigrees, so it opens him up to being versatile for breeders and trainers when looking where to go with their mares. For what he brings to the table, you'd be hard pressed to find a better value for your money.

If I've got a mare that could use help from a stallion physically, what can Charming Kitten best contribute to the equation?

Wolfe: The feedback we have received from the breeders of his first crop (now yearlings), is that he improved every mare – no joke. Large, correct foals with great minds. Strong foals with great bone from the start. And, to be fair, these are reports from owners that bred one or two mares to him – not just a single owner. He has 15 or so yearlings from just as many owners.

What would a breeder looking to harness the Kitten's Joy sire line find familiar in Charming Kitten?

Wolfe: After seeing this first crop hit the ground, and mature into yearlings, all I can say is that a breeder will realize quite quickly that Charming Kitten will continue the legacy of producing winners. I have full confidence in that. His prowess and demeanor are immediately evident, but the real kicker is that he's passing that on as a sire. He is most definitely producing athletes.

What makes Charming Kitten a good fit for the Indiana program?

Wolfe: He's a great fit for the Indiana program because he's a unique pedigree with a lot of class. Indiana is growing. Better class horses are coming to the state, as it should be, and he's a perfect example of that. He brings athleticism that will be successful at long and short distance. He's improving mares, and he's going to produce horses that can win in conditioned or opened races. Why not have an Indiana-sired condition advantage on top of a horse that can win an open race?

Why should a breeder outside of Indiana consider Charming Kitten?

Wolfe: Similar concept to the last question. The horses produced by Charming Kitten will be versatile. Kitten's Joy has shown us without a doubt the success that this pedigree brings to the table. Do you want to pay $50,000 for Kitten's Joy in 2022, or do you want to produce a similar athlete for $2,500 by breeding to Charming Kitten?  Charming Kitten is worth way more, but we want people to feel safe and good about breeding to him – so, let's do it.

Charming Kitten did his best work going over especially long routes of ground. How do you think that should inform the types of mares that breeders should send to him to best fit Indiana's stakes program, where turf races top out at 1 1/16 miles?

Wolfe: We're seeing a lot of “speedballs” in Indiana. Break fast, quick start, and then die out. We're breeding too much speed and no endurance. These mare owners need to look at outcrosses that make sense to improve a mare's produce record. Charming is versatile, and his pedigree is as well. It's not restricted to just long routes, but he certainly can help improve that for mare's when it comes to their offspring and it should be considered.

What are some of the common traits that you've seen among Charming Kitten's first foals?

Wolfe: The breeders have all said the same thing: The foals are large, strong, great bone and correct conformation. Excellent demeanor and easy to work with. We didn't get a single criticism from any breeders this year; just that they absolutely loved their foals (now yearlings).

Charming Kitten was Grade 1-placed over synthetic and ran respectably over dirt in the 2013 Kentucky Derby. Do you see reasons for optimism that he might be able to sire successful runners on surfaces beyond turf?

Wolfe: Most definitely. His record shows his prowess over dirt and synthetic. He finished third in the Grade 1 Blue Grass Stakes over the synthetic at Keeeneland. He finished ninth in the Kentucky Derby on the dirt (outracing Palace Malice and Goldencents). He's a versatile horse and we're going to see that in his offspring.

What's something about Charming Kitten that you think goes overlooked?

Wolfe: His demeanor. It may not be the “top of the list” for breeders, but it should be. This horse is nothing but class. You can handle him with ease, he's respectful, listens, and knows his job. His foals have shown the same demeanor, so we have very trainable, correct athletes. Total package.

What else should breeders know about Charming Kitten before picking up the phone?

Wolfe: We're here to ensure success. We're a part of the team, and we're all friends. When you breed to Charming Kitten, we'll be here for you through it all.

Source of original post

Tom’s D’Etat And The Stud Deal That Could Have Changed Everything

Tom's d'Etat was one of three horses that stepped off the van at the WinStar Farm stallion complex on Sunday morning, less than 24 hours after each ran in the Breeders' Cup Classic at Keeneland just a few miles away.

For his two fellow passengers, a future at WinStar Farm was practically guaranteed as soon as they jumped through the proper hoops to warrant a stud career. Improbable and Global Campaign, second and third respectively in the Classic, both had run under the WinStar colors, so standing at the farm was the next logical step. For Tom's d'Etat, a future at WinStar marks an incredible reversal of fortune from one that could have seen him begin his stud career in relative obscurity.

Looking back at his full body of work, a major Kentucky farm seems like a logical destination for Tom's d'Etat. An earner of more than $1.7 million, he established himself as one of the top runners of the older male division in 2020, and he carried over the momentum from a win in the Grade 1 Clark Stakes last year. Being what will likely be the final top-level son by his late sire Smart Strike to enter stud certainly doesn't hurt, either, joining the likes of Curlin, English Channel, Lookin At Lucky, and Dominus among Kentucky's stallion ranks.

In the summer of 2017, Tom's d'Etat was none of those things, besides a son of Smart Strike. He was a dependable 4-year-old allowance-level runner for the Benson family's G M B Racing and trainer Al Stall, Jr., but after missing his juvenile season due to injury and needing a few tries to break his maiden in the fall of his 3-year-old campaign, a future as a serious Kentucky stallion prospect seemed like a pipe dream.

Tom's d'Etat was trending in the right direction during that year's Saratoga meet, and he was being pointed toward the G1 Woodward Stakes after winning an optional claiming race by nine lengths.

That optional claimer would be the final race of Tom's d'Etat's 2017 campaign. An emerging cannon bone fracture derailed a planned graded stakes debut in the G1 Woodward Stakes, and he went dormant for 15 months after having two screws put in his right front leg.

When his future as an on-track competitor was still murky, Stall and his team wanted to make sure their well-blooded loyal soldier had a future lined up for him after the races.

“There was a time when I was going to give him to the starter at Churchill and Keeneland, Scott Jordan, who has a farm in Indiana [Breakway Farm in Dillsboro, Ind.] – give him to him – and he said, 'I'll hustle up some mares. We don't have any Smart Strike blood in Indiana,'” Stall said. “Then, for whatever reason, everything started staying together on him, and he finally got to prove the kind of talent we always thought he was.”

He'd have been a solid addition to the Breakway Farm roster, but far from its most proven member on the racetrack. In 2020, Grade 1 winners Calculator and Turbo Compressor, Grade 3 winner Charming Kitten, and Grade 1-placed Greeley's Conquest resided in their stud barn.

Tara Mathias, manager of Breakway Farm and Jordan's daughter, said the arrangement never got further than conversations as a contingency plan if Tom's d'Etat couldn't make it back from his injury, and ink was never put to paper over it. There were no hard feelings when the horse went on to achieve what he did and move higher up ladder as a stallion prospect, though having a horse with Grade 1 talent in him slip away from the farm's grasp was a downer.

“Al's exercise rider at the time said he was a really nice horse, and was probably going to retire, and he'd be a good fit in Indiana,” Mathias said, “Then, he just kept winning and winning, and got better and better. They just didn't know how he was going to come back from it, and he didn't have enough under his belt to make him a huge hit in Kentucky. He'd be big in our small pond.”

Normally, a layoff of that duration is enough to retire an older horse, but Tom's d'Etat rewarded the patience of his connections by retaining his up-and-coming form when he returned. Horse racing is a sport full of diverging paths, and the decision to keep Tom's d'Etat in training ultimately created a seven-figure swing in on-track earnings, with the added ripple effects tied to all the graded black type that would have gone to someone else, the money spent and earned in a major Kentucky stud deal, and all the mares he will see in 2021 and beyond.

Tom's d'Etat raced twice at five, culminating in his first stakes triumph in the Tenacious Stakes at the Fair Grounds. He was overmatched in his first try against graded stakes competition in the G1 Pegasus World Cup Invitational Stakes, but he came back after a spring freshening to finish second in the G2 Alysheba Stakes and third in the G2 Stephen Foster Stakes.

From that point on, Tom's d'Etat was in the mix against the best in his division – often as the oldest horse in the field. He finished his 6-year-old campaign with victories in the G2 Fayette Stakes and G1 Clark Stakes, then he racked up wins this year in the Oaklawn Mile Stakes and G2 Stephen Foster Stakes this year at age seven.

In July, following his 4 1/4-length Stephen Foster victory, WinStar Farm revealed it had secured Tom's d'Etat's breeding rights when he retired to stud. From a horse that was perhaps one relapsed injury away from going to stud as a giveaway, Tom's d'Etat had become a blue-chip prospect recruited by one of Kentucky's top stallion operations.

Tom's d'Etat came up empty in his swan song, finishing out of the money in the Breeders' Cup Classic, but Stall said there was never a doubt that he belonged in the race, and amongst the best in his division.

“I'm very, very biased, but I thought he was the best looking horse in the field in the Classic,” he said. “He was moving really well. I just think those two races this summer back-to-back, the Foster and the Whitney, maybe were just enough for him at this age. That would just be my guess, because he was giving us every indication he was going fine, but he's a smart old boy, and maybe that was one of the contributing factors.”

So now, three years after his future looked to be in Indiana, Tom's d'Etat could realistically fit nearly half the Hoosier State's broodmare population into his projected debut book at stud. He'll stand for $17,500 in his debut season, and in addition to his graded-level success, WinStar Farm's Elliott Walden was quick to note that he's got a stallion's family under him.

“Being by Smart Strike, from the family of Candy Ride, that's two proven stallions,” Walden said. “He moves with a very lengthy stride, full of quality. He has the length of a Candy Ride, Smart Strike kind of look to him; similar to Lookin At Lucky, just a long, two-turn type horse.”

Plenty of words have been written at this point about the “win now” mentality of the commercial stallion market, and a prospect that didn't race at two and didn't win until the fall of his 3-year-old season might give some pause about what kind of precociousness Tom's d'Etat may or may not pass on to his foals.

Stall said the horse's slow start was more about bad luck and bad timing than him not being ready for the races.

“He would have have probably broken his maiden in his second start during the Keeneland fall meet, like Blame did as a 2-year-old,” Stall said, projecting his talent had he stayed healthy. “I just breezed him one day at Churchill Downs, and everything was fine with him, then something just flaked off and cost us a year. It wasn't like he was some big horse that didn't know what he was doing. A few things just started adding up. It wouldn't surprise me if he got a typier, smaller horse that would be a decent fall 2-year-old. That's the fun of it. It takes a bit of patience, but that's okay.”

Sunday's transition from the racetrack to the stud barn was a familiar one for Stall, who sent Blame on a van from Churchill Downs to Claiborne Farm ten years earlier after the colt shocked the world to best Zenyatta and win the Breeders' Cup Classic.

In the time between, Stall said he has been fascinated seeing what types of mares worked and didn't work when matched with Blame. Now, he's got another stallion to watch and theorize on matings, and based on the page under Tom's d'Etat and the multi-surface success of Smart Strike, he has at least one outside-the-box idea before the breeding season begins.

“Theoretically, there should be some grass there, even though we tried him on grass, and he did literally everything but stop and graze the day we ran him on it,” he said. “Blame's a good grass sire and he never set foot on the grass.”

The post Tom’s D’Etat And The Stud Deal That Could Have Changed Everything appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Breakway Farm In Indiana To Host Virtual Farm Tour

Breakway Farm, located in central Indiana is offering a virtual farm tour and stallion showcase on its Facebook page on Sept. 15 starting at noon EDT.

In operation since 1995, Breakway Farm is the home to some of Indiana's top stallions and is excited to present two new stallions for the 2021 breeding season during its virtual stallion show. The stallion show and virtual farm tour will feature owner Janice Jordan and farm manager Tara Mathias sharing information on their breeding and boarding farm and how breeders can participate in the lucrative Indiana Thoroughbred Breed Development Program.

New stallions Calculator and Charming Kitten will be introduced to potential breeders.

Calculator (In Summation – Back To Basics, by Alphabet Soup) was the winner of the Grade 3 Sham Stakes at Santa Anita in 2015 and Grade 1 placed, who retired with lifetime earnings of more than $694,000. The gray stallion brings new blood and outcrosses to the state of Indiana and its breeding program.

“Calculator is a great addition to our breeding program because he is an outcross to so many mares,” said Mathias, manager of Breakway Farm.

Millionaire Charming Kitten also joined the stallion roster at Breakway Farm in 2020. The 10-year-old son of Kitten's Joy (out of The Wild Again mare Iteration) won or placed in eight graded stakes, including a victory in the G3 W.L. McKnight Handicap and a third-place finish in the 2013 G1 Toyota Blue Grass Stakes, prior to starting in the Kentucky Derby. The breeding of Charming Kitten fits in with the racing program at Indiana Grand Racing & Casino, where more turf racing is being featured.

“Charming Kitten is a good fit,” says Mathias. “We're excited to stand a son of top sire Kitten's Joy in Indiana.”

Other stallions standing at Breakway Farm that will be featured in the virtual stallion show include:

  • Greeley's Conquest (Mr. Greeley – Tipsy Girl)
  • Mondavi (Maria's Mon, – Senate Appointee), sire of 2019 Swifty Sired Stakes winner Marilyn Mongo
  • Skylord (Sky Mesa – Skyscape), sire of 2018 two-time stakes winner It's Just Fate and two-time William Henry Harrison Stakes winner Double Tuff
  • Turbo Compressor (Halo's Image – Dixieland Event)

“We are excited about the 2021 breeding season,” says farm owner Janice Jordan. “So, we welcome everyone to tune into our virtual stallion show and farm tour.”

The virtual stallion show and farm tour starts at noon EDT and can be found at: http://facebook.com/breakwayfarm

The post Breakway Farm In Indiana To Host Virtual Farm Tour appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights