‘She Could End Up At The Breeders’ Cup’: Warm Heart Earns Free Berth In ‘Classy’ Yorkshire Oaks Win

Mrs. John Magnier, Michael Tabor, Derrick Smith, Westerberg's Warm Heart (IRE) narrowly got the better of Free Wind (IRE) Thursday in a stirring finish to the 1 1/2-mile Pertemps Network Yorkshire Oaks (G1) at York. The daughter of Galileo (IRE) earned an automatic starting position in the $2 million Maker's Mark Breeders' Cup Filly & Mare Turf (G1) through the Breeders' Cup Challenge Series: Win and You're In.

The Breeders' Cup Challenge Series is an international series of 80 Graded/Group stakes races whose winners receive automatic starting positions and fees paid into a corresponding race of the Breeders' Cup World Championships, scheduled to be held Nov. 3-4 at Santa Anita Park in Arcadia, California.

After finishing behind stable companion Savethelastdance (IRE) and Bluestocking (GB) on soft ground in the July 22 Juddmonte Irish Oaks (G1), Warm Heart, ridden by James Doyle, bounced back to the form which saw her win the Ribblesdale Stakes (G2) at Royal Ascot in June.

After 10-3 favorite Savethelastdance set the pace under Ryan Moore, Warm Heart, off at odds of 9-1, traveled powerfully up the York straight and took up the running from her stable companion after passing the 2-furlong marker. Her main danger appeared to be the John and Thady Gosden-trained Free Wind, a 5-year-old mare who was also bouncing back from a poor run on heavy ground at Goodwood last time out. The duo locked horns but it was Warm Heart who found plenty to win by a head. Savethelastdance finished 2 1/4-lengths back in third.

Warm Heart completed the 1 1/2 miles in 2:25:86 over nine rivals on a surface listed as good to firm.

Aidan O'Brien, who won the £500,000 contest for the seventh time, said: “It just didn't happen in the Irish Oaks. The ground was a little bit on the slow side. She was lovely today. She's a very classy filly and you saw what she did in the Ribblesdale.”

O'Brien also suggested Warm Heart she could end up at Santa Anita in November.

“Warm Heart handles the better ground very well, so it's not a problem with her,” he said. “She can do anything. She could end up at the Breeders' Cup.”

O'Brien saddled Tuesday (IRE) to win last year's Maker's Mark Breeders' Cup Filly & Mare Turf at Keeneland.

As part of the benefits of the Challenge Series, Breeders' Cup will pay the entry fees for Warm Heart to start in the Breeders' Cup Filly & Mare Turf at Santa Anita, which will be run at 1 1/4 miles. Breeders' Cup will also provide a travel allowance for all starters based outside of North America to compete in the World Championships. The Challenge winner must be nominated to the Breeders' Cup program by the Championships' pre-entry deadline of Oct. 23 to receive the rewards.

The post ‘She Could End Up At The Breeders’ Cup’: Warm Heart Earns Free Berth In ‘Classy’ Yorkshire Oaks Win appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Attorneys: Track Relationship With State Racing Commissions Complicates Facility’s Right To Exclude Trainers

For the last two years, the topic of racetrack bans against trainers has been widely discussed among people who are both fans of horse racing and legal minutiae. The subject was a focus of one session at the recent Racing And Gaming Conference at Saratoga, where four attorneys examined the question of how these exclusions work, and how the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority may change them in the future.

The question of whether or not a racetrack can ban a trainer on the basis of its private property rights has become one of greater interest since Churchill Downs and the New York Racing Association chose to exclude trainer Bob Baffert after Medina Spirit's positive drug test in the 2021 Kentucky Derby.

Historically speaking, it's uncommon for a racetrack to choose this course of action, according to panelist Alan Foreman, who is chairman and CEO of the Thoroughbred Horsemen's Association and general counsel to the Maryland THA.

“It very rarely happens and it's usually done for political purposes,” said Foreman. “Most of them were reactions to media coverage or public interest in the image of the industry, so tracks would act out. Typically a track, if they wanted to exclude somebody but they knew what the implications of that would be, they'd call the trainer and say, 'Look, you've got to get out of here. We're not going to say anything but you go somewhere else. We don't want you here.' … That was part of the undercurrent for why we have HISA, because bad actors were going around to other places.”

Like almost anything else in horse racing, private property exclusions are not handled uniformly around the country.

“Exclusion at racetracks depends on what jurisdiction you're in,” said panel moderator Bennett Liebman, government lawyer in residence at Albany Law School in New York. “At some racetracks it's virtually impossible to exclude licensees. Traditionally that's been the case in Louisiana. In others it's been fairly easy, such as Ohio. It can even vary within the jurisdiction. It's extremely difficult and time-consuming, although not impossible as we've seen, for NYRA to exclude a licensee but it's far easier for the New York harness tracks to exclude licensees.”

Foreman recalled the landmark Maryland case of trainer Nick Lemberos, who he described as a “thorn in the side” of racetracks in the state. Lemberos applied for stalls at Timonium and was granted a single stall, and was then told to vacate the stalls he had at Laurel. Lemberos moved his horses to the receiving barn and when the stewards suspended him, he sued seemingly everyone – the state commission, the stewards, the racetracks, and a number of individuals. His argument was that he was entitled to a due process hearing from the racetrack before the property could exclude him, because the trainer's license he'd been issued by the state gave him a right to be on the property. Because he didn't get a due process hearing, he believed he was not only entitled to an injunction against the ban but to damages.

Support our journalism

If you appreciate our work, you can support us by subscribing to our Patreon stream. Learn more.

The judge applied two tests to the case to determine whether Lemberos had a valid point, analyzing the history of racing and racetracks in Maryland to understand the relationship between the facilities and the state regulators

“They ended up concluding there was no relationship that would cause the track owners to be what are called state actors,” said Foreman, which upheld the track's right to exclude the trainer.

The court did find that the stewards should have given the Lemberos a hearing before suspending him, however.

In subsequent cases about private property exclusions, similar questions have been posed about whether a racetrack may be considered an agent of the state. Several panelists expressed surprise that in the case between Bob Baffert and NYRA, the racing organization didn't offer him a due process hearing at the jump to avoid the inevitable legal argument about it later. Liebman believes that, since a judge required this process take place in the Baffert case, NYRA will probably be less likely to take action against other licensees in the future, now that it understands how time-consuming and complicated the hearing process would be.

None of the panelists were sure how the implementation of HISA would change the ability or interest of tracks to exclude trainers.

“I think HISA takes the position that as it relates to medication, safety and welfare, which is their space, that they preempt state law, so therefore the track does not have the right of exclusion,” said Foreman. “I'm not sure that's a correct interpretation.”

Regardless, Foreman believes that national, uniform regulation via HISA may, in some cases, negate tracks' appetite to take similar actions to the Baffert case.

[Story Continues Below]

“At the time of the Baffert case there was extraordinary frustration among a number of track owners that the regulatory system was not dealing with frequent violators,” said Foreman.

Before the Baffert exclusion, trainer Jerry Hollendorfer was excluded from Stronach Group racetracks after the ownership group noted concerns about the number of catastrophic breakdowns his barn experienced during the Santa Anita fatality spike in 2019. It remains unclear, Foreman said, whether HISA would or could initiate a similar action against Hollendorfer were the same situation to occur today.

Louis Trombetta, executive director of the Florida Gaming Control Commission, expressed concern about whether exclusion was still an option in cases where HISA is taking enforcement action. As has been previously reported, trainers on provisional suspension by HISA see no change to their state license status and can still access the backstretch, although they're not allowed to enter their horses in races.

“We're worried about how someone who is suspended under HISA would be treated if we were worried about them being a paper trainer and HISA wasn't taking care of it,” said Trombetta. “That's a situation where, in the past, we might look towards exclusion in that type of case.”

The post Attorneys: Track Relationship With State Racing Commissions Complicates Facility’s Right To Exclude Trainers appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Del Mar Community Bouncing Back From Tropical Storm Hilary

Things are getting back to normal at Del Mar following last Sunday's rain from Tropical Storm Hilary. There are still some remnants of the storm. Large puddles of water and mud remain in parts of the stable area but, for the most part, everything has dried out nicely and the pens and walking rings are back in use.

Rain gauges on the backside measured 2 ½ inches of liquid by the time Hilary exited Del Mar, enough to flood some areas between the stables, though the stalls and the horses themselves remained dry.

“We were pretty fortunate,” trainer Peter Eurton says. “Being on this end (of the backside) is flat and has a little better drainage.”

“We did have a little water in between,” trainer Marcelo Polanco says about his barn, “but on the sides nothing happened.”

About 80 horses were transported off the grounds and sent to either Los Alamitos or San Luis Rey. These were horses who are normally kept outside in pens and were vulnerable to the weather conditions. Some were moved inside but once the empty stalls were filled, the excess had to be shipped out temporarily.

Both dirt tracks were open Tuesday but only for jogging, no galloping or works were allowed. Training resumed Wednesday. Racing returns on Thursday.

The post Del Mar Community Bouncing Back From Tropical Storm Hilary appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Pletcher Facing Third Medication Suspension From 2022 After Mind Control DQed From Parx Dirt Mile Victory

It took seven minutes for Todd Pletcher-trained Mind Control to be elevated by the stewards from second place to victory in the 2022 Parx Dirt Mile Stakes and 11 months for the Stay Thirsty colt to be disqualified from the win for a positive drug test.

Second under the wire, beaten a neck at 3-5 odds by 12-1 longshot Far Mo Power in the $200,000 race last Sept. 24, Mind Control was awarded the win after stewards disqualified the first-place finisher for interference in the stretch. Officials denied Far Mo Power's connections – trainer Louis Linder Jr. and owner Joseph E. Sutton – an opportunity to appeal the decision, but they ultimately wound up getting the win after Mind Control tested positive for the diuretic hydrochlorothiazide at the Pennsylvania Horse Racing Commission's official laboratory. A split sample confirmed the presence of the drug in plasma.

According to an article from the University of California-Davis school of veterinary medicine, hydrochlorothiazide can be used as a treatment for hyperkalemic periodic paralysis (HYPP) by reducing the amount of potassium in the blood. The Association of Racing Commissioners International lists it as a Class 4 drug with a Class B penalty.

A hearing at Parx Racing before the board of stewards was conducted 45 weeks after the race, on Aug. 9, 2023, with Pletcher appearing by telephone and his attorney, Karen Murphy, in person

After considering all the testimony and evidence, stewards ruled on Aug. 18 that Mind Control be disqualified and placed last, with Pletcher suspended 15 days and fined $500. Mind Control's owners, Red Oak Stable and Madaket Stable, will be required to forfeit the first-place purse of $114,000, with Far Mo Power now declared the winner, Dontmesawithme, second, and New Commission third.

The disqualification does not affect pari-mutuel results.

The case preceded the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority and its Anti-Doping and Medication Control program as the national oversight agency for medication issues.

Pletcher said an appeal has been filed in the case. The ruling called for his suspension to run from Aug. 30-Sept. 13 but it is expected he will receive a stay.

The Hall of Fame horseman is now facing three separate suspensions from 2022: 14 days for a July 30 positive test for phenylbutazone in the horse Capensis at Saratoga, and 10 days for a Sept. 5 positive test for meloxicam in Forte, winner of the G1 Hopeful at Saratoga. Those violations are also being appealed and Pletcher has received a stay of the suspensions.

Mind Control, a Grade 1 winner of the Hopeful at 2, the H. Allen Jerkens at 3, and the Cigar Mile at 6, was retired at the end of 2022 and is standing at stud in New York.

The post Pletcher Facing Third Medication Suspension From 2022 After Mind Control DQed From Parx Dirt Mile Victory appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights