Texas Judge Upholds Constitutionality Of Horseracing Integrity And Safety Authority Act

A federal judge in Lubbock, Texas, has ruled for the second time the federal legislation that established the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority does not violate the U.S. Constitution.

U.S. District Court Judge James Wesley Hendrix, in a memorandum opinion and order issued Thursday, said the National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association and other plaintiffs in a 2021 lawsuit failed to show that HISA – passed by Congress in December 2020 and amended in December 2022 after the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the original legislation unconstitutional – “continues to violate the Constitution.”

The key to the Hendrix ruling was the December 2022 amendment giving the Federal Trade Commission greater authority in its oversight of HISA. The Fifth Circuit opinion overturning Hendrix's original ruling found that the FTC played a “subordinate” role to HISA and remanded the case back to Hendrix and the District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Lubbock Division.

Between that November 2022 ruling and a one-day bench trial on April 26, Congress responded to the Fifth Circuit opinion by inserting language into an omnibus spending bill that allowed the FTC to “abrogate, add to, and modify” the rules of the Authority.

“In light of Congress' amendment to HISA and the undisputed evidence following a bench trial, each of (plaintiffs') arguments falls short,” Hendrix wrote.

The National HBPA and numerous affiliates were joined in the suit by racetrack owners in Texas, the Texas Horsemen's Partnership, the state of Texas and the Texas Racing Commission, bringing additional constitutional arguments to the complaint.

“Now that Congress expressly authorizes the FTC to modify the Authority's rules,” Hendrix wrote, “the plaintiffs retreat and admit their true view: that there is nothing Congress could do to bring the HISA-Authority arrangement within constitutional bounds.”

Hendrix struck down all of the additional arguments from those plaintiffs. His order cited what he called a “persuasive opinion” by the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, which found HISA constitutional after the insertion of the December 2022 amendment.

“We appreciate the Federal District Court's re-affirmation of HISA's constitutionality,” a statement from HISA said following the order. “The urgent need for nationwide, uniform rules to enhance the safety and integrity of Thoroughbred racing has never been clearer. We look forward to the resumption of HISA's Anti-Doping and Medication Control program on May 22, as ordered by the Federal Trade Commission.”

HISA's Racetrack Safety program went into effect July 1, 2022, but the Anti-Doping and Medication Control program has been delayed several times, by the FTC and then by a different federal judge who ruled the FTC failed to follow its own rules in approving medication regulations. The latest delay, from a May 1 start to May 22, was ordered by the FTC to help horsemen competing in the first two legs of the Triple Crown to avoid confusion about the new medication regulations.

Eric Hamelback, the National HBPA president, issued the following statement: “We've been down this road before. After a loss in the District Court, we secured a win in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. We will win there again. We will fight to protect horsemen and their constitutional rights all the way to the Supreme Court if needed.”

U.S. District Court Memorandum Opinion and Order

 

The post Texas Judge Upholds Constitutionality Of Horseracing Integrity And Safety Authority Act appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Federal Judge Rules HISA Constitutional After Law’s Rewrite

The revamped Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (HISA) statute that got signed into law back in December was judged to be constitutional late on Thursday by the Texas federal district judge handling the case on remand from the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

“Congress answered the call-identifying the three constitutional concerns that led the Fifth Circuit to hold HISA unconstitutional and rectifying each with the amendment,” wrote United States District Court Judge James Wesley Hendrix in his May 4 order out of the Northern District of Texas (Lubbock Division).

“The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) can now initiate rulemaking according to its own policy preferences,” Hendrix wrote.

“Given the Court's findings of fact and conclusions of law, the plaintiffs fail to establish that HISA, as amended following the Fifth Circuit's opinion, continues to violate the Constitution,” Hendrix wrote. “The Court denies all other requested relief.”

The HISA Authority issued a statement in the aftermath of the ruling that said, “We appreciate the Federal District Court's re-affirmation of HISA's constitutionality. The urgent need for nationwide, uniform rules to enhance the safety and integrity of Thoroughbred racing has never been clearer. We look forward to the resumption of HISA's Anti-Doping and Medication Control program on May 22, as ordered by the FTC.”

The court order delivers a legal blow to efforts by the National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (NHBPA), which had initiated the underlying lawsuit along with 12 of its affiliates in 2021. But Thursday's ruling won't end the case.

“We plan an immediate appeal of this decision, and we remain confident in our legal arguments,” Daniel Suhr, the lead attorney representing the NHBPA, stated in a press release. “Congress cannot abdicate its authority to a private corporation. Challenging this law is critical to protecting democratic accountability enshrined in our constitution.”

Eric Hamelback, the NHBPA's chief executive officer, stated in the same release that, “We've been down this road before. After a loss in the district court, we secured a win in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. We will win there again, We will fight to protect horsemen and their constitutional rights all the way to the Supreme Court if needed.”

The NHBPA's case was later joined by other intervenors in Texas and private racetrack entities in that same state who had their case recently transferred to the Lubbock Division because of the overlapping nature of the complaints. The defendants are personnel from the HISA Authority and the FTC.

Hendrix was the same judge who, back on March 31, 2022, dismissed the NHBPA's underlying lawsuit, writing in an order that “despite its novelty, [HISA] as constructed stays within current constitutional limitations as defined by the Supreme Court and the Fifth Circuit.”

The NHBPA plaintiffs appealed that decision, leading to the Fifth Circuit's reversal on Nov. 18, 2022. That ruling stated HISA was unconstitutional because it “delegates unsupervised government power to a private entity,” and thus “violates the private non-delegation doctrine.”

But the Fifth Circuit's order also remanded the case back to the Lubbock Division for “further proceedings consistent with” the Appeals Court's reversal.

In the interim, Congress passed and President Biden signed into law on Dec. 29 an amendment to HISA designed to bring the law into constitutional compliance consistent with the Fifth Circuit's identified flaws.

“The Court finds that the congressional amendment to § 3053(e) cured the constitutional issues identified by the Fifth Circuit,” Hendrix wrote in his May 4 order. “First, the Fifth Circuit identified that HISA improperly granted the Authority 'sweeping rulemaking power,' but the FTC's new power to 'abrogate, add to, and modify' the 'rules of the Authority' closed the necessary gap in the relative rulemaking power between the FTC and the Authority.

“Second, the Fifth Circuit noted that the FTC's review of Authority rulemaking was limited to so-called consistency review, which gave the Authority the final word on policy. But because the FTC now has the right to make its own policy choices, the amendment remedied that concern,” Hendrix wrote.

“In sum, the only fair reading of the statute is that the FTC can create new rules as necessary to accomplish its policy preferences,” Hendrix wrote.

“It is no secret that Congress amended HISA in response to the Fifth Circuit's opinion. For Congress to amend the law without addressing one of the critical issues identified by the Fifth Circuit would be, to say the least, unusual,” Hendrix wrote.

“For all these reasons, the Court rejects the plaintiffs' arguments and conclude that Congress cured the unconstitutional aspects of HISA's original approach,” Hendrix wrote

The post Federal Judge Rules HISA Constitutional After Law’s Rewrite appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

Continuar Out Of Derby, King Russell In As Last AE

Lion Horse Race Co. Ltd.'s Continuar (Jpn) (Drefong) will reportedly be scratched from this year's GI Kentucky Derby, according to trainer Yoshito Yahagi.

“After evaluating the colt upon my arrival, I feel that he has not been able to reach the peak fitness required to take on a race as tough as the Kentucky Derby,” Yahagi said. “Considering the future of the horse and the fact that we cannot show the horse's true ability in his current state, we have decided to scratch Continuar from the Kentucky Derby. I am very sorry that I cannot participate in the world's number one horse racing festival, however I sincerely hope to return to the Derby in the future. I want to thank everyone who has supported Continuar and Yahagi Stable on this journey.”

Continuar qualified for the Kentucky Derby through the Japan Road to the Kentucky Derby point series where he received an invitation to compete in the first leg of the Triple Crown. With this defection, Brereton Jones and Naber Racing's King Russell (Creative Cause), trained by Ron Moquett, will draw into the field and break from the outside post 20. The program number 23 will remain the same. King Russell will be ridden by Rafael Bejarano.

“You can't help but feel for the ones that scratch,” Moquett said by phone, when asked about the news that his horse had drawn in. “This is an opportunity for the team, our owners and we have been here all week preparing just like King Russell was already entered. We know he is special horse and like Babe Ruth calling his shot, I predicted that he would finish in the top three in the Arkansas Derby and that he would be in the [Kentucky] Derby. Here we are. After the training, pointing him here, galloping, schooling, we are going to see if he can get the mile and a quarter. I've been here before with Far Right in 2015 and that following year with Whitmore, and now it is time to get down to business because we are wanting to do more.”

Scratch time for Kentucky Derby 149 is Friday at 9 a.m. ET.

The post Continuar Out Of Derby, King Russell In As Last AE appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights