Sixth Circuit: No Rehearing On HISA Constitutionality Decision

The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled Thursday that it will not grant a full-court rehearing to the losing plaintiffs who contested a three-judge panel's Mar. 3 decision to uphold the constitutionality of the Horse Racing Integrity and Safety Act (HISA).

The case is one of five anti-HISA constitutionality lawsuits currently active in the federal court system. Led by the states of Oklahoma, West Virginia and Louisiana, the plaintiffs collectively petitioned Apr. 17 for a rarely granted “en banc” procedure that asked for a rehearing before all 28 of the Sixth Circuit's judges instead of just the panel of three who had ruled that a change of language in the HISA law was sufficient to alleviate the plaintiffs' concerns over constitutionality.

“The court received a petition for rehearing en banc. The original panel has reviewed the petition for rehearing and concludes that the issues raised in the petition were fully considered upon the original submission and decision of the case. The petition then was circulated to the full court. No judge has requested a vote on the suggestion for rehearing en banc. Therefore, the petition is denied,” the May 18 order stated in its entirety.

A United States Court of Appeals explanatory page about how en banc requests work stated that the granting of that type of rehearing was “rare” at the federal level. The Sixth Circuit took on only seven en banc hearings between January 2018 and September 2021, according to the University of Cincinnati Law Review.

Beyond the above-mentioned states, the plaintiffs include the racing commissions from Oklahoma and West Virginia, plus three Oklahoma tracks (Remington Park, Will Rogers Downs and Fair Meadows), the Oklahoma Quarter Horse Association, the U.S. Trotting Association, and Hanover Shoe Farms, a Pennsylvania Standardbred breeding entity.

The defendants are the United States of America, the HISA Authority, and six individuals acting in their official capacities for the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).

The underlying lawsuit dates to Apr. 26, 2021, when the plaintiffs sued, alleging that “HISA gives a private corporation broad regulatory authority.”

On June 2, 2022, that claim was dismissed by a judge in U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Kentucky (Lexington) for failure to state a claim of action. The plaintiffs then appealed to the U.S. Sixth Circuit.

In between the filing of that appeal and the Sixth Circuit's decision on it, an updated version of HISA was passed into law Dec. 29, 2022, with the aim of fixing constitutional flaws that a separate Fifth Circuit appeal had identified.

The Mar. 3 order by the Sixth Circuit affirmed the constitutionality of the amended HISA law. On remand from the Fifth Circuit, a United States District Court judge in Texas did the same thing May 4.

In its Apr. 17 rehearing petition, the plaintiffs had stated that parts of the panel's decision were “erroneous, and this Court should rehear the case en banc in order to resolve those questions of exceptional importance.”

Thursday's ruling by the Sixth Circuit disagreed.

The post Sixth Circuit: No Rehearing On HISA Constitutionality Decision appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

York: All Eyes On Gold Cup-Bound Eldar Eldarov In The Yorkshire Cup

Friday's G2 Boodles Yorkshire Cup features two high-class veterans in the G2 Lonsdale Cup winner Quickthorn (GB) (Nathaniel {Ire}) and Broome (Ire) (Australia {GB}) whose reinvention as a stayer was confirmed with a G2 Dubai Gold Cup success, but it could be that youth counts as Eldar Eldarov (GB) (Dubawi {Ire}) makes his seasonal return in the 14-furlong feature. Primed for two major efforts at three when successful in Royal Ascot's G2 Queen's Vase and the G1 St Leger at Doncaster, KHK Racing's flagbearer was only seventh stretching out to two miles in the G2 British Champions Long Distance Cup but is back in his sphere of comfort here. “He's really doing well of late and has obviously been very good at both tries over this distance,” trainer Roger Varian said. “We do see him being very effective when he races over Cup distances, but I think a mile and six furlongs is a good distance to start his season off at, and we hope he runs a good, solid race on Friday that means we can then take aim at the Gold Cup at Royal Ascot.”

The Quick And The Dead

In a strong year for the stayers, the incredible 14-length success of Quickthorn in the two-mile Lonsdale Cup was one of the peak performances of 2022. Trainer Hughie Morrison believes that the impact of that wide-margin win from Coltrane (Ire) (Mastercraftsman {Ire}) was lost after his subsequent heavy defeats in the G1 Prix du Cadran and British Champions Long Distance Cup. Lady Blyth's homebred was also sixth behind Broome in the Dubai Gold Cup and the trainer is hoping he can arrest the worrying declining trend. “My concern is that I might have left my year behind in Dubai, but I've been perfectly happy with him at home,” he told the Qipco British Champions Series. “It wasn't easy getting him out of a field in December to have him ready for a fast-ground race in Dubai that looked like a group one three months later.”

“It was a Flightline-type performance, but he didn't get the Flightline-type recognition,” Morrison added of the Lonsdale Cup victory. “It might have been a once-in-a-lifetime performance, but I do think it was exceptional, and the disappointment was that neither Stradivarius nor Trueshan ran that day because we'd have got the credit then. Coltrane obviously didn't run to his best, but Quickthorn absolutely dominated him and I think if you look at the sectionals, he went fast all of the way. The ground had gone when he went to Longchamp, and it was the same story at Ascot. The year before he'd had enough by October, and I think that was probably a factor again, too.”

Marygate Poser

Friday's undercard at York includes the 19th edition of the five-furlong Listed Clipper EBF Marygate Fillies' S. which has attracted a trio of juveniles by first-crop sires. Chief among them is Amo Racing's TDN Rising Star Persian Dreamer (Calyx {GB}), one of two representing Dominic Ffrench Davis, who bids to underline a stunning debut performance at Newmarket last month. Her contemporaries include race sponsor Clipper Logistics' Newmarket runner-up Dorothy Lawrence (GB) (Soldier's Call {GB}) from the double-handed Karl Burke team and the once-raced Brian Ellison trainee Callianassa (Ire) (Invincible Army {Ire}).

Queen Bee?

Also on Friday is a potentially talent-rich renewal of the Listed Oaks Farm Stables Fillies' S., where Normandie Stud's TDN Rising Star Queen For You (Ire) (Kingman {GB}) bids to take further steps towards the G1 Coronation S. won by her dam Fallen For You (GB) (Dansili {GB}) 11 years ago. With the John and Thady Gosden stable which houses its usual quota of high-class fillies, she made the ideal start at Ascot early this month and Thady is hoping she keeps building. “She seems to have come forward for the run and although it is a big jump up into listed company, we'd be hopeful,” he said. Also engaged in what could be a key prep for the Royal Ascot fillies' feature is Godolphin's Newmarket maiden winner Silver Lady (GB) (Sea The Stars {Ire}), a daughter of Lumiere (GB) (Shamardal), and James Wigan's Haydock scorer Stormy Sea (GB) (Territories {Ire}), a half-sister to Bay Bridge (GB) (New Bay {GB}).

Next Stop Emily Dickinson

Last year's renewal of Leopardstown's G3 Saval Beg Levmoss S. saw the arrival front-and-centre of Ballydoyle's Kyprios (Ire) (Galileo {Ire}) on the stayers' scene with a 14-length success in the 14-furlong Gold Cup prep and Friday's edition sees the stable's more-than-able deputy Emily Dickinson (Ire) (Dubawi {Ire}). Demonstrative when ending her 3-year-old campaign and beginning her current season with clear-cut wins in the division's key Irish races, the G3 Loughbrown S. and Listed Vintage Crop S., the daughter of Chicquita (Ire) (Montjeu {Ire}) bids to win over Ryan Moore who dashes here from York after partnering another potential Gold Cup ride in Broome (Ire) (Australia {GB}).

Modern Games Stars In Lockinge Field

Godolphin's G1 Poule d'Essai des Poulains, GI Woodbine Mile and GI Breeders' Cup Mile hero Modern Games (Ire) (Dubawi {Ire}) will face 12 rivals in Saturday's G1 Al Shaqab Lockinge S. at Newbury. Charlie Appleby reported the 2022 Eclipse Champion Male Turf Horse, who was second in Keeneland's GI Maker's Mark Mile last month, to be raring to go for the mile feature for which he is drawn on the wing. “Hopefully, this will be the opportunity for Modern Games to win a Group 1 in the UK. The Maker's Mark Mile proved a strangely-run race from our perspective, but he came out of it well and heads to Newbury in great shape. We know that he is a crack miler and he goes here with the benefit of a run under his belt. Conditions at Newbury should suit, especially with the drying ground, and he is going to be a big player.”

John and Thady Gosden supply Juddmonte's TDN Rising Star and G1 Sun Chariot S. runner-up Laurel (GB) (Kingman {GB}), while fellow Newmarket raider My Prospero (Ire) (Iffraaj {GB}) kickstarts his 4-year-old campaign having finished third in the G1 Champion S. at Ascot in October. He is drawn next to Modern Games in 12, while Sheikh Ahmed Al Maktoum's Jadoomi (Fr) (Holy Roman Emperor {Ire}), who finished third behind Bayside Boy (Ire) (New Bay {GB}) and Modern Games in the G1 Queen Elizabeth II S., is drawn on the other extreme in one.

The post York: All Eyes On Gold Cup-Bound Eldar Eldarov In The Yorkshire Cup appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

Jockeys’ Kindness Overwhelms Mage Owner Norma Barnes-Euresti In Midst Of Childhood Dream

Fifty years and a day after the start of a lifetime of intense love of horses and racing Norma Barnes-Euresti found herself at the center of a memorable few minutes on the track at Churchill Downs May 6.

Barnes-Euresti, a co-owner of the Kentucky Derby (G1) winner Mage, was on her way to the special Derby winner's circle in the infield but was having trouble getting through the deep dirt surface in her wheelchair. Seeing that her friend was struggling to pull Barnes-Euresti backwards across the track, jockeys Gerardo Corrales and Jose Ortiz decided to participate in what turned into a special delivery.

“Corrales and Ortiz were so kind as to just come over,” Barnes-Euresti said. “They picked me up and started helping carry me across the track. Then, when you get over to the winner's circle area, there are these concrete steps that go up into that area. Those gentlemen were just so kind and so classy as to carry me up those steps and set me down.

“It was just a great moment, on top of a great moment that they were so kind. They had just ridden in a big race themselves, and they weren't done for the day. The fact that they just came up and just helped, I can't tell you what that means to me.”

Barnes-Euresti, an investor in the Commonwealth partnership (listed as CMNWLTH in the program) that owns a 25 percent share in Mage, participated in the post-Derby festivities. Unlike most of the others celebrating Mage's score, she had Derby-winning experience as a Myracehorse.com partner in 2020 victor Authentic. She will be at Pimlico Race Course for the first time Saturday when Mage faces seven challengers in the 148th Preakness Stakes (G1).

NBC Sports' winner's circle host Ahmed Fareed saw the jockeys do their good work and did an interview with Barnes-Euresti, whose mobility is limited by an underlying physical condition.

“As soon as the microphone went away,” she said, “I had this moment of 'I don't even know what I said' and if I had been coherent because I was just so excited to have Mage win, and my heart was just so full from the kindness of the two jockeys to help in that moment. I think I was shouting. I think I was excited. I don't know that I did justice to the love I felt for everyone in that moment, but I did my best for somebody who was a little overwhelmed.”

Barnes-Euresti, the Chief Legal Officer Designate for the WK Kellogg Co., precisely traces her connection to racing to May 5, 1973. when Secretariat began his Triple Crown run in the Derby. She was in kindergarten.

“I was watching that race with my dad on TV, and I was just so struck by Penny Chenery being his owner,” Barnes-Euresti said. “In that moment, I just wanted to be her and I just became kind of horse crazy as a child afterwards. I read everything I could. Every toy that belonged to me was some horse-related toy. I had a hobby horse. I had those little Breyer horses. I used to put them in the front basket on my bicycle and I would imagine that this is what I was doing.

Four years later, she and her father, Michael, watched Seattle Slew, whose owners included Karen Taylor, start his Triple Crown sweep in the Derby.

“That was when I first kind of voiced to him this desire that I had to do that,” she said “I said to him, 'someday that's going to be us. We're going to be in the winner's circle after winning the Kentucky Derby.' And my dad said, 'They don't call it the Sport of Kings for nothing kid. I hate to tell you this, but you were not born into royalty or into people that own horses.'”

However, Barnes-Euresti said her father encouraged her to think big.

She recalls him telling her: 'Don't let anyone take your dreams. If this is something you're really interested in, then it has to be something more than what you daydream about. Right? You have to actually believe that you can do it and then you're going to have to figure out a plan of how are you going to get there because I'm sure that these folks had a plan of how they were going to get there.'

“Penny Chenery certainly had a little bit of a different plan because her father was involved. Karen, as far as we knew, at that time, didn't have that experience. But she had a plan, and she made it happen. She took steps to make it happen.”

Barnes-Euresti said she dove into horses and racing. She consumed all the books about horses she could find in the library and bought others that she saw advertised. Her family was living in Utah at the time, and she said her father had a friend who was into Quarter Horse racing. They would drive to Pocatello, Idaho to watch the horses compete.

“I asked all these questions, and I got jobs working at horse farms so I could learn how to ride,” she said. “I cleaned a lot of stalls and brushed a lot of horses, and, frankly, I loved every moment of it. I did jobs like that all the way up through being in law school.”

Twenty years after being captivated by Chenery and Secretariat, Barnes-Euestri was a young professional still determined to be an owner. She saw an advertisement in a Chicago newspaper offering shares in some standardbred horses and climbed aboard. Now, 30 years later, she said she has had an ownership stake in approximately 75 horses. Most of the group are Thoroughbreds in flat racing, but she has also owned shares in steeplechase horses and standardbreds. The most accomplished of her harness horses was Wiggle It Jiggle It, winner of the 2015 Little Brown Jug.

“I treat it the same way that anyone running a horse farm does,” she said. “I look for the horses that are out there that you can invest in. I read their pedigrees. I've studied that quite a bit. I watch their works if they're available. Then I make my selections. I've had a lot of fun and a lot of luck with that over the years.”

With Commonwealth, she is a partner in Country Grammer, winner of the 2022 Dubai World Cup (G1) who has earned over $14 million. Through Myracehorse.com she has a stake in 2022 Prince of Wales Stakes winner Duke of Love. During her three decades in the sport Barnes-Euresti, a resident of Battle Creek, Mich., said she has had shares in between 25 and 30 graded stakes winners.

“I've been very fortunate that way,” she said. “The thing that my father impressed on me when I first had this goal for sure is that you'll probably have to have a team around you to do this with. Everyone who's successful has a team. People try to say they were self-made, and they're just not grateful enough to the people who helped them. He said, 'just think about the team, that you're evaluating them as much as you do the horses.'”

Barnes-Eurestri said her father's advice was not to be too focused on the goal and to enjoy the people she would meet along the way.

“Has he ever been right about that. I have to tell you, a lot of people when they talk about going to the Derby – I've seen it because I love it. I've watched every edition since Secretariat won – you hear people talk about, it's a fairy tale come true. And it's definitely that.”

Even though she is a seasoned owner of horses, Barnes-Euestri said she was inexplicably touched by Mage. She purchased a higher-level stake in the Good Magic colt for herself and has made good use of the $50 micro-shares that Commonwealth offers.

“When I saw him in November there was something so special about him that I gave Commonwealth shares in him to friends and family for the holidays as a present because I just had a feeling,” she said. “I can't really explain it and it probably makes me sound like I think I have more skill than I probably really do. There's something that you feel when you see him, that there's something special about him.”

It has turned out that Barnes-Euresti was right about Mage's ability and acknowledges that she is wrapped up in the story that surrounds the colt trained by Gustavo Delgado and his son Gustavo Delgado Jr. The critical first step of the tale took place a year ago, then Delgado Jr. and his partner Ramiro Restrepo went over their budget to purchase the 2-year-old colt for $290,000 at auction. They needed some other investors and brought in Sterling Racing and Commonwealth.

“The people who are part of the team, they're all very different, but love is the common denominator,” she said. “A love of horses and horse racing. A love of Mage and his incredible heart and spirit, his will to win. His love of running and the love you see that he has for the people who surrounded him.

“If you've heard the story of Gustavo Jr. and Ramiro, and how they bid on him, the fact that they just had that faith in themselves and the faith in this horse that they saw, to think he could be something,” she continued. “To me, that is just how I think about it. I feel like it's a love story. And I felt that way the first time I saw him.”

During the week before the race, Barnes-Eusteri made a point of visiting the Kentucky Derby Museum to see the new exhibit Secretariat: America's Horse. She said she felt like her late father was with her and that she directed some thoughts toward him and the woman who was her inspiration.

“There's this lovely picture there in the hall with Penny Chenery and Secretariat. I had my picture taken in front of that,” she said. “And I was like, 'I don't know if you can hear me, but I want to say thank you because she gave a little girl a dream. And you made me believe that I could actually get here not having any of the connections or horses that people usually have to lead them to that place.”

The post Jockeys’ Kindness Overwhelms Mage Owner Norma Barnes-Euresti In Midst Of Childhood Dream appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Stakes-Winning Montauk Traffic A Healing Presence At Lucky Orphans Horse Rescue

Each May, Mental Health Awareness Month is recognized nationwide to bring attention to the importance of mental healthcare. Among the many therapies available to those with mental health struggles is equine assisted therapy, a horsemanship-based program that provides support to patients.

Lucky Orphans Horse Rescue, located in Dover Plains, New York, is one of several programs across the country that offers equine assisted therapy, utilizing horses like stakes-winner Montauk Traffic to create a meaningful and healing connection with the organization's clients.

The late-running Montauk Traffic, who was campaigned by trainer Linda Rice and owner Chris Fountoukis, won 4-of-10 starts led by a victory in the $100,000 Jimmy Winkfield in 2020 at Aqueduct Racetrack. An injury in the summer of 2021 marked the end of his racing career and destined him for a quieter life without any further riding. But despite his physical limitations, Montauk Traffic has excelled at a newfound second career as a therapy horse.

Retired to the organization in the fall of 2021, Montauk Traffic now works closely with Lucky Orphans' clients, teaching them patience and general equine husbandry skills as they work through an array of psychological challenges, including depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), attention deficit disorder, and autism, among others. The New York State Department of Health notes that each year, more than 1 in 5 New Yorkers display symptoms of a mental disorder.

Deanna Mancuso, founder and executive director of Lucky Orphans, said Montauk Traffic, or “Monte” as he's known around the barn, has turned into an exceptional teacher and listener.

“He's a little different than some other horses when you think of horses with second careers,” said Mancuso. “He has a fairly active career here and just the other day he spent two hours with some college psychology students. He is also part of the volunteer training to teach new volunteers about horse safety and communication. He's very responsive and super sensitive, so he's a great part of our program.”

Lucky Orphans, one of 81 organizations accredited by the Thoroughbred Aftercare Alliance (TAA), was founded by Mancuso with the mission, “people helping horses help people.” Mancuso, who previously ran a for-profit boarding center, was frequently asked to take in horses in need of proper sanctuary, and decided in 2013 to convert her business into a 501(c)3 non-profit equine rescue.

With her herd of rescued horses, Mancuso began to develop programs based on lessons taught to her by her grandfather, lessons that made her realize how her organization could help not just animals, but people, too.

“My grandfather was in the Korean War and when he returned home and suffered from PTSD, he said it was always a horse who brought him out of his darkest times,” Mancuso recalled. “Before he died of pancreatic cancer, he bought me a horse to help me through my dark times. All of our programs are based around that model of horses helping people get through anything.”

Monte is one of 49 horses, 20 of them thoroughbreds, that call Lucky Orphans home. He was placed there through the efforts of his former connections and the New York Thoroughbred Horsemen's Association's (NYTHA) TAKE THE LEAD program, which provides funds for veterinary exams and assistance in placing horses in new homes and careers once their racing careers have ended.

The New York Racing Association, Inc. (NYRA) and its horsemen are dedicated supporters of both the TAA and NYTHA's TAKE THE LEAD programs, with every owner competing on the NYRA circuit donating $10 per start to the TAA and 1.5 percent of the purchase price of all claimed horses on the circuit to TAA and TAKE THE LEAD. Since 2014, this program has raised nearly $2 million collectively in support of aftercare.

While Monte has become an invaluable asset to Lucky Orphans' programs, it was not always apparent the son of Cross Traffic would settle well into a quieter routine on the farm. Mancuso said it took plenty of handling and desensitizing to get Monte adjusted to life as a therapy horse.

“Looking at him and how powerful he was on the track is exactly how he is on the farm,” said Mancuso. “He went through a bit of a change and he kept acting like, 'When's the next race?' After he was gelded, he was unpredictable and had some behaviors that made us wonder where he fit into the program. We worked with him and got him to settle, and now he's so social and curious, intrigued by people and whatever is going on.”

The time Mancuso and the volunteers spent with Monte proved well worth the effort. While all the program horses are capable of supporting and teaching Lucky Orphans' clients, Monte in particular has struck a chord with many. As a stakes-winning racehorse who overcame injury to live a meaningful life in retirement, Monte and his story provide even the most withdrawn clients with hope and inspiration.

“Here you have this amazing athlete who was eligible for the Breeders' Cup, had so many come-from-behind victories, and had to retire,” said Mancuso. “This really resonates with our veterans – being at your prime and then having setbacks that they do not know how to process. These horses are amazing for that because they shift gears so much in retirement. He provides a level of support that they need.”

Mancuso said Monte is a prime example of the way thoroughbreds can happily transition to second careers beyond riding and jumping.

“A lot of people think we have a lot of limitations here because we don't ride them, but we enjoy these horses so much,” said Mancuso. “To share what they can do for our clients is really life changing.”

Monte participates in introductory education where new clients learn about general horsemanship and equine behavior, which leads into individually tailored program sessions.

“We have our clients tell us about themselves, we set goals, and then we teach about safety with the horses,” said Mancuso. “Depending on the goals, we'll then set up with activities that includes grooming of the horses, leading them through obstacle courses, or having them open up and communicate with the horse. Even if we can't hear them, it gets them talking out loud. It's customized to each client and the sessions end with a discussion about what they've learned and assignment of homework around that.”

Mancuso explained that the program's success can be attributed to the deep-rooted connections between horses and humans, and that to care for them is to care for each other.

“Horses have built who we are as a society,” said Mancuso. “Aftercare is so important as it shows our responsibility to the animal. It's an invaluable thing, and to see what the thoroughbred industry is doing for aftercare is priceless for the people and the horses.”

Lucky Orphans, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, is accredited by the Academy of Prosocial Learning, Natural Lifemanship, and Arenas For Change. For more information and to make a donation, visit https://www.luckyorphans.org/. 

The post Stakes-Winning Montauk Traffic A Healing Presence At Lucky Orphans Horse Rescue appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights