Tinky: The Met Mile Rescheduling A Business Win? Not So Fast, Ray

While I typically find Ray's View From the Eighth Pole columns to be insightful, his most recent offering appears as though it may have been written on one of those foggy Saratoga mornings when it's difficult to see the finish line 100 feet out, let alone from an eighth of a mile.

The problem that I have with his conclusion, which is neatly summarized in the title of his piece, is that he attempts to support it through the use of highly misleading data, derived from this chart:

The simple reason that the data shown is misleading is because it is not inflation adjusted, and the extreme impact of the resulting miscalculations can be understood when considering his primary claims. First, we have this:

To their credit, NYRA has grown Memorial Day handle back to where it was in the Met Mile days, now focusing on a good day of racing to showcase New York-breds

a claim that is patently false.

The $16 million figure representing the Memorial Day handle in 2013 is actually equivalent to $20 million in 2022 inflation-adjusted dollars. So, in an apples to apples comparison, the 2022 figure ($14 million) reveals a $6 million, or ~30 percent decline in real dollars. A 30 percent decline!

This is Ray's other central claim:

Making Belmont Stakes Day as strong a day of racing as there is this side of the Breeders' Cup has helped handle, especially when a horse is going for the Triple Crown.

First, we have no idea if, or to what degree moving the Met Mile (and two other races) has impacted handle in Triple Crown editions of Belmont days. It's just not possible to judge with any confidence, as the only three which fell into that category over the past 25 years occurred after the change, and are extreme outliers.

But setting aside those special days, it is possible to accurately judge the relative handles when there were no TC contenders. I won't use 2012 data, as there was hype around I'll Have Another, even though he was scratched the day before the event. In 2013, there was ~$89 million wagered, which is equivalent to ~$112 million inflation-adjusted (2022) dollars. In 2022, the handle was ~$99 million, which means that in real dollars, there was a ~$13 million, or ~12% decline in wagering.

These two simple, yet obviously important adjustments, not only undercut Ray's claim that the move of the Met Mile “proved” to be a good business decision by NYRA, but suggest the opposite!

I will assume that Ray is correct about NYRA retaining a higher percentage of simulcast wagering on Belmont days, and ideally, that should be factored into the adjusted data. But even if it were (I have no access to the relevant details), it seems highly unlikely that it would significantly alter the basic picture.

Full disclosure: I was unhappy with the move originally, and criticized it publicly at the time. But as Daniel Patrick Moynihan famously said, 'Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts.”

–Tinky

******************

Tinky is the nom de plume of a student of the game who developed a passion for Thoroughbred racing in the mid-1970s, and has been an industry professional for ~four decades (and counting). He also has a long-standing history of commenting publicly on various racing-related sites around the internet, including The Paulick Report.

If you would like to submit a letter to the editor, please write to info at paulickreport.com and include contact information where you may be reached if editorial staff have any questions.

The post Tinky: The Met Mile Rescheduling A Business Win? Not So Fast, Ray appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.

Source of original post

Caravel to Skip Royal Ascot, Aim for Jaipur

Quatar Racing, Marc Detampel and Madaket Stable's Caravel (Mizzen Mast), winner of last year's GI Breeders' Cup Turf Sprint, will skip an expected trip to Royal Ascot for the June 20 G1 King's Stand S. and will instead aim for the June 10 GI Jaipur S. at Belmont Park, trainer Brad Cox confirmed Tuesday. The news was first reported by the Daily Racing Form's Dave Grening.

“We just feel it's the right decision with getting her back to the Breeders' Cup,” Cox said.

Purchased for $500,000 at the 2021 Fasig-Tipton November sale, Caravel won the GIII Franklin S. before her front-running victory in the Turf Sprint last November. Scratched from the Keeneland November sale just days after that win, the 6-year-old mare returned this term with a determined score in the Apr. 8 GII Shakertown S. and added a win in the Unbridled Sidney S. at Churchill Downs in her most recent start May 5.

The six-furlong Jaipur is part of the Breeders' Cup challenge series and offers an automatic berth in this year's Turf Sprint, which will be held at Santa Anita Nov. 4.

The post Caravel to Skip Royal Ascot, Aim for Jaipur appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

Menuisier Hoping Heartache Can Continue Wonderful Story

Eric Clapton has already inadvertently provided owner Chris Wright and trainer David Menuisier with one Group 1-winning filly in the form of Wonderful Tonight (Fr) (Le Havre {Ire}) and now it's up to The Eagles. 

Former record company boss Wright has a long history of naming his horses after song titles, and when it came to the half-sister to the multiple group winner, the selection of Heartache Tonight (Fr) (Recorder {GB}) seemed fitting. There may well have been a little heartache involved, too, as at the time she was signed up as a private purchase at Arqana's October Yearling Sale, her elder-sister had only recently exited stage left, her season and career curtailed by injury. By that stage, however, Wonderful Tonight had already won the G1 Prix Vermeille and G1 QIPCO British Champion Fillies & Mares S., as well as the G2 Hardwicke S at Royal Ascot and the G2 Lillie Langtry S. at Goodwood, her local track.

Now in her place at Menuisier's Sussex stable is her three-year-old sibling, who on Friday will become her trainer's first runner in a British Classic. Like Menuisier, Heartache Tonight was born and bred in France, but they have both migrated across the Channel. Despite Britain now being the filly's permanent base, she has raced solely in her native country in her three starts to date. 

By the Sumbe sire Recorder, a son of Galileo (Ire) bred by Her Late Majesty the Queen, Heartache Tonight is out of the Montjeu (Ire) mare Salvation (GB) and was herself bred by Sylvain Vidal, the former head of Haras de Montfort & Preaux, where the Sumbe stallions reside. 

Menuisier demonstrates his trademark sangfroid when it comes to lining up at Epsom. “We're keeping our feet on the ground,” he says. 

“The main plan has always been and will still remain the autumn for this filly. She will have a break after this and she will be trained for the Arc. If she's not good enough we can bring her back. That said, I wouldn't run [in the Oaks] if I didn't think she has a chance, but I personally feel no pressure about Friday.”

No box-walking for the trainer, then, and he is justified in his belief that his filly, who runs in the colours of Chris Wright in partnership with Andy MacDonald, deserves her place in the line-up. 

Heartache Tonight was the easy winner of her sole start at two, which came on heavy turf and over nine furlongs at Lonchamp. She returned to Paris in April for the G3 Prix Cleopatre, in which she was beaten just over a length when third behind Crown Princesse (Fr) and Elusive Princess (Fr). All three were pitched straight into Group 1 company for their next start in the Prix Saint-Alary and finished second, third and fourth behind Jannah Rose (Ire), with a length and a half separating the quartet. 

“I think that the two trials she ran in were interesting races and they came across as being of a good level,” says Menuisier. “When we ran in the Cleopatre, she was the only filly making her seasonal debut in the race and it was only her second race ever. We don't train on turf here, we train on wood chip, so it was her second time on the grass and I thought she ran a strong race.

“She was always going to need the run. A furlong and a half out she looked like she was getting swamped but then she had a little breather and picked up again, so that was a really good performance.”

He continues, “We decided to aim high and I said at the time that we would only run in the Saint-Alary on soft ground, because I think that she would have lacked a little pace to have won over 1m2f on good ground. 

“It was a bit of a stop-and-start race, but it was the same again, and when they quickened, she looked like she was getting swamped again, but then she picked up and rallied and was only beaten a length and a half. The second and the third were the fillies who finished just in front of her in the Cleopatre, so the form repeated itself and the filly gained experience. She was really green at Saint-Cloud but she's learning all the time and we feel at home that she has improved more since the Group 1 than she did between the Group 3 and the Group 1. So, we'll see.”

Stepping up to the mile and a half of the Oaks test, rather than remaining at the shorter distance for the Prix de Diane, especially now that the ground has dried out significantly, will suit Heartache Tonight, according to her trainer. 

“I think she wants 1m4f to compete at the top level. It's great to go and run in France but every time it is a long journey. We're only 45 minutes from Epsom so it's perfect to run here.”

It is only natural to draw comparisons between half-sisters, especially when they emanate from the same stable, but Menuisier outlines one key difference in the make-up of Heartache Tonight.

He says, “This filly is very similar to her sister in many ways. She has a strong temperament but she is so much easier to train than Wonderful Tonight. This one is pretty bombproof, and I'd be surprised if she was fazed by the preliminaries. When she ran at Longchamp, she stayed in Chantilly and travelled over to the racecourse in the morning, and it was quite busy at the track and the stables were packed but she didn't turn a hair. She was sleeping flat out in her box before the race. She has the constitution to go to war in the big races.”

Menuisier adds, “It's a fantastic story for everybody really. What is the chance of having two sisters competing at Group 1 level, especially when you buy them at the sales? It's pretty exceptional.”

The post Menuisier Hoping Heartache Can Continue Wonderful Story appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

Source of original post

Verified by MonsterInsights