Author: News
Nancy Messineo Bequeaths Surprise Windfall to California Horse Charities
Some wear their philanthropic largesse as visibly as the Great Wall of China from outer space.
Others prefer a more discreet badge.
“I only found out about this three days ago,” said Lucinda Lovitt early Tuesday morning. Lovitt is the executive director of the California Retirement Management Account (CARMA), the non-profit founded 15 years ago to raise money for the state's fleet of retired racehorses.
Lovitt's weekend discovery? That CARMA was one of a handful of racehorse rehoming and animal rescue organizations bequeathed–and bequeathed without their prior knowledge–a sizeable sum of money by Nancy Messineo, who passed away on June 8 at the age of 74 after a long battle with cancer.
Messineo was a California racehorse owner fiercely devoted to the wellbeing of the animals in her care–and quite evidently, those in others' care, too.
“This is quintessential California horseracing,” Lovitt added, still a little taken aback by the donation. “Someone who wants to make an impact that is so understated and quiet, but who just wants to do right by the horses.”
Lovitt isn't the only recipient just recently finding out about the donations.
“You assume the what now?” said Dianne Nelson, co-founder of the Wild Horse Sanctuary in Northern California, across a spotty phoneline.
“I'm assuming this is the first you're hearing of it?” this reporter responded.
“Absolutely,” Nelson replied, with the bemused air of a lottery winner not quite believing the numbers before them. “I'm a bit speechless.”
Susan Peirce is the president and founder of the Chino Hills, Los Angeles-based Red Bucket Rescue that saves slaughter-bound, starving, neglected and traumatized horses. She initially asked for a little time to absorb the news.
“What a wonderful, wonderful gift,” Peirce said, given a few hours to reflect. “There's this amazing shining light and gift that Nancy left that speaks to her character and love of horses and desire to see this work continue and that's astounding. It's humbling–it really is.”
Bruce Sands is a long-time friend of Messineo's, and a co-owner with her on many horses down the years.
He said Messineo, who made her money as a realtor, left CARMA, the Wild Horse Sanctuary, Red Bucket Sanctuary, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and the Thoroughbred Charities of America sums totaling roughly three-quarters of her estate.
While Sands didn't publicly disclose the sum total, the contributions amount to a significant portion of the annual operating expenses for the first three charities at a minimum.
The least surprising part of this whole bittersweet affair is that Messineo has taken such pains to support these various organizations. “She just loved animals,” he said.
The two met in 2007. “We had a dog in common as well as the horses. I gave her a Golden Retriever, Sierra, as a birthday present about 14 years ago. In fact, she's here with me right now,” Sands said, the sound of a rubbed ear making its way down the telephone line.
Their first horse was called Practical, who they had in training with Mike Pender. When it came time to name the son of Notional, they hit a bit of writers' block.
“Nancy said to herself, 'well I just need to be practical about this.' And that's where the name came from,” said Sands.
After a fashion and inspired by the lightning-bolt successes of Marley's Freedom–campaigned by her good friends, Barb and Ron Perry–Messineo's dreams started to take on new dimensions. “All she wanted was a horse in a stakes race,” said Sands.
Messineo got more than that in Oscar Dominguez, who won the GII Hollywood Turf Club S. at Del Mar in 2019 with a gladiator's challenge down the homestretch.
“That was probably our biggest victory because he was such a longshot,” said Sands, of the horse's unexpected victory that day over the Richard Mandella-trained hotpot, United.
The way Sands describes Messineo's relationship with horse racing is as someone who took sustenance from the sport the way a rock climber draws air at altitude. “All of it–she loved all of it,” he said, of a woman whose living room wall is emblazoned with win pictures. Twenty-five of them, if you count.
“There was a time we were going to the morning workouts a lot,” he said. The backstretch, too, was home from home for her. “She loved to visit her horses.”
When at the track, “she was always making new friends.” And when she wasn't racing, “she watched the races all the time at home on TV.”
Throughout Messineo's long illness, she credited the horses for being her most potent medicine.
“She always used to tell me, 'It's the horses that keep me going, it's the horses that keep me going'” said trainer Richard Baltas, who conditioned Oscar Dominguez, adding how the horse is now in happy retirement in Southern California, roaming the trails of Trifecta Farms.
“Even when she was really sick, she still wanted to come to the track,” Baltas remembered. “She was just deeply passionate about the horse business.”
“I'm pretty sure the horses did keep her alive,” agreed Barb Perry, who struck up a firm friendship with Messineo. “One of the reasons we became friends was because she loved her horses so much.”
Just take Beyond Pleasure, a filly that Messineo, Sands, Ron and Barb Perry were partners in.
When Beyond Pleasure was claimed from the barn, Messineo and Barb Perry both tracked her progress. And when the filly retired, they reached out to the trainer to have her back. But the trainer had already found the filly a home–she's a jumper now for a girl in Arizona.
“We just wanted to make sure that when the horse retired she was looked after,” said Perry. “That's what Nancy did. She put her horses first.”
The charities approached for this story all stressed the different and often difficult circumstances that make Messineo's largesse either so desperately needed, desperately appreciated or both.
“It's incredible actually because we do struggle–I don't know a non-profit, especially in the horse world, that doesn't struggle,” said Nelson.
She talked about sleepless nights worrying about where the next load of hay will come from, and about the costs from old fences rotting away. This at a ranch with 14 miles of perimeter fence needing to be maintained.
“It ensures that we're going to be here for a number of years to come,” said Nelson. “And also that we're going to be able to rescue more horses.”
For CARMA, Lovitt said that while they haven't even begun to think about how the organization might use the additional funds, she discussed the need to create something for Messineo that honors her legacy on the California racing industry.
“As a recipient of a gift like this, we should be quietly grateful and furiously getting to work on fulfilling what Nancy would have wanted, which is that the horses she was so passionate about and cared so much about have the best opportunity in their next career,” said Lovitt, who said these kind of posthumous gifts are pretty rare for CARMA.
“The impact for a small charity like this is long-lasting,” Lovitt added. “We have the opportunity to create programs or services that can thrive beyond the initial bequest.”
For Peirce, she described a farm struggling to stay afloat, both literally and figuratively.
“We had a really hard winter,” said Peirce, pointing to the harsh winter storms that have drenched California.
“We're at the very bottom of the valley. And so, everything we had washed into the creek. We lost a barn–every barn flooded. We've lost all of our ground cover. And we have so much deferred maintenance–we need about a quarter of a million dollars to replace just our fences,” she said.
“Times are really tough right now, so there's the business piece to it,” said Peirce. She also mentioned a growing movement to euthanize horses deemed difficult or impossible to rehome, and to lower adoption standards–a movement that runs counter to the governing ethos of her charity.
“Those are things that we hold so important. We stand firmly on the side of protecting and preserving life,” said Peirce. “It's getting harder to do that, and this is a wonderful boost for us.”
“I am beyond grateful,” she added, her voice thickening over the telephone line. “And I wish I could tell Nancy that myself.”
The post Nancy Messineo Bequeaths Surprise Windfall to California Horse Charities appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.
Book Review: Alydar’s Chief Counsel
If there was a Thoroughbred who ever needed legal counsel to mount an adequate defense of his life, then perhaps it would be Calumet Farm's MGISW Alydar.
His battles with rival Affirmed as both a juvenile, and of course, through the 1978 Triple Crown are now the stuff of legend. However, what has clouded all those spectacular past performances came during his stallion career when he tragically died from an injury which was sustained while he was in his Calumet stall on a November night in 1990. Officially chalked up as an accident, his sudden and shocking death has remained shrouded in conjecture ever since.
What happened to Alydar? That is the central question that Fred M. Kray attempts to tackle in his ambitiously titled new book, Broken: The Suspicious Death of Alydar and the End of Horse Racing's Golden Age.
There is nothing quite like a tenacious true crime writer. Plucky isn't a descriptor that goes far enough. It's one's dogged determination, coupled with an ability to stare deep into the abyss that demands sterner stuff. Kray has all of that and more. His passion for this topic is evident, and he possesses the requisite skills to follow a labyrinth of clues and misstatements that go back forty-plus years.
A former animal-rights attorney who was on hand to witness the John M. Veitch trainee when he won the 1978 GI Flamingo S. at Hialeah Park and the GI Florida Derby at Gulfstream Park, Kray began to delve into the case in 2018. He tried to track down those involved, performed seemingly countless interviews and attempted to weave together a story chock full of contradiction.
But has Kray actually uncovered a smoking gun or is this just a series of red herrings? Where exactly is the conspiracy to commit murder?
Broken flows rather like a true crime memoir. It's Kray's defense laid bare on behalf of the Thoroughbred in question. Committing the cardinal sin if we skip to the end of this mystery, the author mythically knots his favorite Windsor tie and strides to the same courtroom in Houston, Texas where the security guard who was on duty that fateful night was tried and sentenced. There, he gives his own account of why he believes Alydar was murdered. It's heartfelt, but somehow it falls just short of compelling drama à la Raymond Burr.
Still, what makes this work a worthy read is the journey. Kray starts with the initial, all-too-brief insurance investigation. He then moves briskly through a composite of Alydar's racing and breeding shed exploits and delves into the questionable economic practices of Calumet's J.T. Lundy & Co. After painstakingly wading through the ensuing trials which fingered less than a handful of Calumet figures, Kray opens the curtain for the final act in which he becomes the lead. Perched on his shoulder like a GoPro Camera, we watch as he sits in front of many a horse farm gate, chides a reluctant private detective who didn't deliver and relates a number of emotional moments with key witnesses.
The relationship he forms with Tom Dixon, the equine insurance agent who was the first on the scene at Calumet, is particularly poignant. Dixon is a no-nonsense umpire that calls them like he sees them, and Kray has to steadily battle for the former agent's uneasy trust in order to access key photographs and notes. 'Deep Throat', Dixon is not, but the back-and-forth between the pair as they argue points of view on several occasions is quite a chess match.
Speaking of emotional moments, Kray's interview with Alydar's groom, Michael Coulter is both enlightening to his case, but we also find a man who hasn't returned to the scene mentally in quite some time. Though a witness in one of the trials, Coulter's perspective was underutilized and from Kray's questions, we get a window into the relationship the groom built with this superb equine athlete. Coulter explains how tired Alydar was from over-breeding and addresses the horse's psychological state. This is important because there were constant questions throughout the different trials about Alydar's penchant for kicking stall doors.
What Kray finds is a trail of dead ends and memories which are parsed with a few nuggets of remembrance. The author leads us to the assumption that key players that do not want to talk are clinging to something deeper. His mission to ask everyone connected why there were no marks on the paint in Alydar's stall, and why the latch was not disturbed becomes an indelible part of the script. A tense section relates an interview with the well-known Dr. Larry Bramlage. It is particularly excruciating to plow through, but it also shows how resolute Kray is when it comes to defending Alydar. You feel both men's frustration bearing out and it makes for good theater in the Rood & Riddle waiting room where the interview was conducted.
There is something very Citizen Kane about Broken. Like the reporter who is sent to find out what Charles Foster Kane meant when he said 'Rosebud' on his deathbed, we may never know what happened to Alydar that night at Calumet in 1990. Was his leg hit with something? Was more than one person involved? Who knew about the coverup at Calumet? Who knows something right now? Questions will continue to float. While we are on a roll, did Kray prove that this was the end of horse racing's 'Golden Age' as the book's subtitle suggests? That answer seems even more amorphous.
Instead, maybe we can take a sliver of comfort in knowing that there are some things we just can't uncover about a tragedy. If you read Broken as an homage to this Thoroughbred, then we need to thank the author for his contribution and determination. What we can say is that if Fred Kray had defended Alydar, at the very least, he might have had his day in court.
Broken: The Suspicions Death of Alydar and the End of Horse Racing's Golden Age by Live Oak Press, 348 pages, photos, May 2023.
The post Book Review: Alydar’s Chief Counsel appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.
Galileo Off The Mark At Royal Ascot As Warm Heart Takes The Ribblesdale
It took its time coming this year, but the expected Royal Ascot winner for the great Galileo (Ire) aptly arrived courtesy of Ballydoyle as Warm Heart (Ire) captured Thursday's G2 Ribblesdale S. for the late legend. Stepping up to a mile-and-a-half trip that was always going to see her excel following her hard-fought win in the 10-furlong Listed Haras de Bouquetot Fillies' Trial S. at Newbury last month, the 13-2 shot was in the right spot early with Ryan Moore's unerring radar to her advantage.
As the initial strong pace slackened notably after the first half mile, Warm Heart was close up while Shadwell's keen-going 5-6 favourite Al Asifah (GB) (Frankel {GB}) was compromised several lengths behind without cover. As Warm Heart took a narrow lead two out, Al Asifah arrived out wide with a threat that was to prove only short-lived as the eventual winner produced a 11.88 split to take command. At the line, the daughter of the triple group 1 winner Sea Siren (Aus) (Fastnet Rock {Aus}) had 2 1/2 lengths to spare over Lumiere Rock (Ire) (Saxon Warrior {Jpn}), with TDN Rising Star Bluestocking (GB) (Camelot {GB}) 1 1/4 lengths further behind in third.
“She is a straightforward filly and they didn't go hard, so I was in a good spot and it all worked out,” Moore said. “She was a better filly today up to a mile and a half.” Aidan O'Brien added, “We thought that a mile and a quarter was maybe as far as she was going to get and we didn't know when she got to the front today whether she would run out of stamina. She got the trip very well today and Ryan gave her a beautiful ride. She's out of a great mare and usually those fillies with good pedigrees do improve–physically she's doing great.”
Al Asifah well-beaten! Warm Heart powers clear to win the Ribblesdale for Aidan O'Brien and Ryan Moore at #RoyalAscot! @Ascot pic.twitter.com/daPyBrdOny
— At The Races (@AtTheRaces) June 22, 2023
Pedigree Notes
Warm Heart is the fifth foal out of Sea Siren, whose top-level victories came in the Manikato S., Doomben 10,000 and BTC Cup. She is also responsible for Galileo's G3 Derrinstown Stud Fillies S. runner-up Celestial Object (Ire) and the stable's ill-fated Arbutus (Ire) who broke down during the Listed Yeats S. last season. The third dam is the G1 Karrakatta Plate winner Hold That Smile (Aus) (Haulpak {Aus}), while the family includes the G2 Bank of New Zealand Breeders' S. scorer and stakes producer Lady Dehere (NZ) (Dehere). Her final Galileo is a 2-year-old colt named Bremen (Ire), after which she produced a yearling colt by Camelot (GB).
Thursday, Royal Ascot, Britain
RIBBLESDALE S.-G2, £235,875, Ascot, 6-22, 3yo, f, 11f 211yT, 2:30.41, g/f.
1–WARM HEART (IRE), 128, f, 3, by Galileo (Ire)
1st Dam: Sea Siren (Aus) (MG1SW-Aus, SW & MGSP-Ire, $1,743,772), by Fastnet Rock (Aus)
2nd Dam: Express A Smile (Aus), by Success Express
3rd Dam: Hold That Smile (Aus), by Haulpak (Aus)
1ST GROUP WIN. O-Mrs J Magnier, M Tabor, D Smith & Westerberg; B-Coolmore (IRE); T-Aidan O'Brien; J-Ryan Moore. £133,765. Lifetime Record: 5-3-1-0, $231,472. *Full to Celestial Object (Ire) (Galileo {Ire}), GSP-Ire. Werk Nick Rating: A. Click for the eNicks report & 5-cross pedigree, or the free Equineline.com catalogue-style pedigree.
2–Lumiere Rock (Ire), 128, f, 3, Saxon Warrior (Jpn)–Last Gold (Fr), by Gold Away (Ire). (55,000gns Ylg '21 TATOCT). O-M O'Flynn; B-The Last Partnership (IRE); T-Joseph O'Brien. £50,713.
3–Bluestocking (GB), 128, f, 3, Camelot (GB)–Emulous (GB), by Dansili (GB). 1ST GROUP BLACK TYPE. O-Juddmonte; B-Juddmonte Farms (East) Ltd (GB); T-Ralph Beckett. £25,380.
Margins: 2HF, 1 1/4, NO. Odds: 6.50, 14.00, 4.50.
Also Ran: Crown Princesse (Fr), Sea Of Roses (GB), Al Asifah (GB), Climate Friendly (GB), Lmay (Ire), Ghara (GB), Village Voice (GB), Perfect Prophet (GB), Understated (GB), Midnight Mile (Ire), Rocha Do Leao (Ire), Red Riding Hood (Ire), Ferrari Queen (Ire), Maman Joon (Ire). Scratched: Infinite Cosmos (Ire), Luckin Brew (Ire).
The post Galileo Off The Mark At Royal Ascot As Warm Heart Takes The Ribblesdale appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.

