As the court battle between Triple Crown-winning owner Zayat Stables and New York investment firm MGG Investments rages on, court documents filed this week show the receiver tasked with managing the diminishing stable has faced a challenge from indicted trainer Jorge Navarro.
Elizabeth Woodward, director of forensic accounting and litigation support at Dean Dorton Allen Ford, was appointed by a Fayette Circuit Court in January to manage the stable's assets. This primarily involves selling horses at public auction or overseeing the continued racing careers of some in hopes of increasing their value. As news spread earlier this year of the suit, which is based on more than $24 million in loans MGG claims Zayat Stables did not repay, other creditors began to emerge
Woodward filed a motion before Judge Kimberly Bunnell this week, asking the court to certify her calculation of money Navarro is owed by the stable. Woodward claims she was in contact with Navarro over the training of Zayat runners Paynted, Mony, and Perlman after being appointed to run the stable in January. Days before his federal indictment in March on charges related to doping of racehorses, Woodward says Navarro asserted a legal claim on the horses for unpaid bills by Zayat. Upon news of his arrest, Woodward said she immediately sought to remove the three horses from Navarro's barn.
Ten days after his arrest by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Navarro informed Woodward through attorney Bradford Beilly he planned to sell the horses to pay off the debt, which he claims exceeds $51,000.
“Contemporaneously with sending its Claim Notice, Navarro transported the Zayat Horses to an undisclosed location, without notice or permission from the Receiver, and in direct violation of the [Court] Order on or around March 19, 2020,” read Woodward's motion. “Escalating the conflict, on April 7, 2020, Navarro then scheduled a public sale for April 17, 2020 … Though it was unclear how Navarro could hold a commercially reasonable public sale as required by Florida statute at a time in which the state was closed for commerce by executive order and the horses themselves were secreted away to an unknown location, the Receiver took immediate steps to stop the proposed sale.”
Woodward secured a bond for the amount Navarro claimed he was owed and secured the horses nine days later and sold them at the Fasig-Tipton July Horses of Racing Age Sale for a combined $112,000.
Because of the specific expenses allowed and disallowed by Florida laws governing liens, Woodward now says the stable owes Navarro less than he claims. Previous findings in the case suggest the receiver isn't subject to bills incurred by the stable under Zayat's control, and only certain types of expenses such as feed and stabling (but not training) are permitted for agister's liens in Florida, according to Woodward's motion.
Rudy Rodriguez was awarded a $394,437.19 judgment for unpaid training bills by a New York court, and is hopeful he can collect his money before MGG is paid back from proceeds of sales or race purses by Zayat horses.
In other news related to the case this week, Judge Bunnell dismissed with prejudice MGG's claims against Bemak International, which facilitated a sale of American Pharoah breeding rights from the Zayat family to Orpendale. MGG is appealing that dismissal.
The post Unpaid Bills And Disappearing Horses: Court Filings Detail Dispute Between Navarro, Zayat Receivership appeared first on Horse Racing News | Paulick Report.
Source of original post
